Eminem's publisher Eight Mile Style filed an amended complaint against AI music startup Suno on November 19, adding 108 alleged AI-generated tracks that it says copy lyrics and musical elements from 26 Eminem-affiliated songs. The filing, made in the Northern District of California, directly challenges Suno's public claims that its platform blocks prompts for specific artists and songs.
The new evidence #
The amended complaint includes what the publisher calls "108 further examples of additional infringing output of twenty-six of the Works" [3]. Those examples are lodged with the court as Collective Exhibit C and linked to a public Vimeo folder. According to Digital Music News, they include a jazz version of "Lose Yourself," a heavy alternative rock take on "The Real Slim Shady," and a DJ-style version of "Without Me" [1]. The 26 songs range from 1999's "Brain Damage" to 2024's "Houdini" and include tracks where Eminem is a featured artist or producer, such as Akon's "Smack That" and 2Pac's "Thugs Get Lonely Too" [3].
The original suit, filed November 6, alleged Suno scraped 269 Eminem works to train its models and generated unauthorized derivative outputs, some mimicking Eminem's voice. The amended complaint keeps the same 269-work count and the same statutory damages demand: up to $47.8 million across copyright infringement and two DMCA claims [1][3].
Responding to Suno's public statements #
The amendment adds a new opening section saying Suno, in a post-filing statement to press outlets, claimed its service does not trade on anyone's name or likeness and does not allow prompts for specific artists' names and songs [3]. Eight Mile Style says those statements are false and that the 108 new examples prove it. The complaint also cites a third-party site, HookGenius, which sells Eminem-style prompts for Suno designed to bypass guardrails, and a Suno-affiliated creator who tutorials how to get around artist-name restrictions [6].
Suno has not yet answered the complaint. In a separate Massachusetts case, Suno argued its outputs do not replicate the auditory characteristics of any real artist's voice to the point that someone would confuse a Suno creation with one actually sung by a particular famous musician [3]. The publisher says the "Slim shady x Rosefalls" track — included in the original filing with a voice clearly derived from Eminem's actual voice — and the new exhibits contradict that claim [6].
Scraping and guardrail allegations #
The amended complaint details how Suno allegedly obtained the training data. It cites a 404 Media report on leaked Suno source code showing the company used Bright Data proxy services to scrape millions of songs and lyrics from YouTube Music, Deezer, and Genius, including 2,057,486 artist records from YouTube Music and 6,980,653 song-page processing records from Genius [6]. It alleges Suno used stream-ripping tools YT-DL and YT-DLP to circumvent YouTube's rolling cipher encryption [6].
The complaint also points to Suno's own admission in the UMG litigation that its training data includes essentially all music files of reasonable quality that are accessible on the open Internet [8]. Suno V6, launched September 2026, now accepts artist-name prompts and redirects them toward descriptive musical characteristics that Suno attributes to that artist — which the complaint frames as a business decision to facilitate facsimiles of copyrighted works [6].
A coordinated wall of complaints #
Eight Mile Style is represented by Richard S. Busch, who also represents Elvis Presley Enterprises, Reservoir, Gerencia 360, and Round Hill Music in similar suits against Suno. All have filed amended complaints adding dozens of specific output examples [1][4]. The Elvis Presley Enterprises amendment added 42 new examples plus 76 outputs tied to songs not in the suit, which the plaintiffs say show wholesale copyright infringement that Suno engages in to this very day [4].
The coordination suggests a strategy: rather than relying on a single test case, rights holders are building parallel complaints each stacked with playable outputs a judge can evaluate. The Presley case is also among the first to test Tennessee's ELVIS Act — which covers simulated voice and tools whose primary purpose or function produces a particular person's voice — in federal court [4].
Procedural posture #
The case was randomly reassigned on November 18 from Magistrate Judge Joseph C. Spero to U.S. District Judge Beth Labson Freeman, vacating a February 2027 case management conference [3][7]. Judge Freeman participates in the court's Cameras in the Courtroom pilot project [7]. Suno has not yet filed a response or motion in this case.
What remains unknown #
- Whether the Vimeo examples play as described; eminemnews.com reported the folder would not load its videos for verification [3] .
- How Suno will defend against the specific outputs: fair use, lack of substantial similarity, or that its guardrails satisfy legal obligations.
- Whether the court will treat the 108 new examples as representative or anecdotal.
- The status of Bright Data: named in the Gerencia 360 and Round Hill suits as a scraping supplier, then dropped; its LinkedIn now lists a primary headquarters in San Francisco rather than Israel [1] .
The amended complaint's message is narrow: the publisher says the outputs kept coming after Suno claimed they couldn't, and it has brought receipts it intends to prove at trial.
Sources #
- Eminem Publisher Files Expanded Suno Copyright and NIL Lawsuit (digitalmusicnews.com)
- Eminem's Publisher Eight Mile Style Expands Copyright and NIL Lawsuit ... (dancehallmag.com)
3. [Eminem Suno Lawsuit: Amended Complaint Adds 108 Tracks From ...](https://eminemnews.com/eight-mile-style-suno-amended-complaint-2026) (eminemnews.com)
4. [Elvis Owners Amend Suno Lawsuit With New Alleged Outputs](https://www.thehypemagazine.com/2026/11/16/elvis-presley-enterprises-amends-suno-lawsuit-outputs) (thehypemagazine.com)
5. [Elvis Presley | Billboard Hot 100 & 200](https://elpee.jp/artist/Elvis%20Presley) (elpee.jp)
6. [EMS v. Suno - First Amended Complaint v3(159482883.3)](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.483293/gov.uscourts.cand.483293.11.0.pdf) (storage.courtlistener.com)
7. [Eight Mile Style, LLC v. Suno, Inc., 3:26-cv-13399 – CourtListener.com](https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/75087642/eight-mile-style-v-suno) (courtlistener.com)
8. [EMS v. Suno - Complaint (Near Final)(159266416.1)](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.483293/gov.uscourts.cand.483293.1.0.pdf) (storage.courtlistener.com)