# xAI tells Ninth Circuit California's AI training data law is unconstitutional

> Source: <https://startupfortune.com/xai-tells-ninth-circuit-californias-ai-training-data-law-is-unconstitutional/>
> Published: 2026-11-19 05:02:22+00:00

*Musk's AI company wants a federal court to stop California from making labs say what their models learned from. If you build or buy generative AI, the ruling will decide how much of your data supply chain has to be public.*

xAI asked a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on Wednesday, November 18, to block California's AB 2013, the state's AI training data transparency law, arguing it's unconstitutional and exposes trade secrets. The case is X.AI LLC v. Bonta, No. 26-1591, heard in Pasadena by Judges Rawlinson, Smith and Forrest, according to the court's docket. MLex reported that the panel gave little sign of how it would rule, pressing both xAI and the state on what the law means in practice.

Newsom signed AB 2013 in September 2024, and it took effect on January 1. It requires developers of generative AI systems to post a summary of the datasets used to train them on their own websites. It asks for high-level information, not the datasets themselves, which is a point California leans on heavily.

xAI's complaint makes two claims. The first is that the law forces the company to hand over trade secrets it values in the billions of dollars. The second is that it compels speech in violation of the First Amendment, because the state is dictating what a company must say about its own product.

It lost the first round. A federal judge in California denied xAI's request for a preliminary injunction earlier this year, and Law360 covered the ruling. The judge, Jesus Bernal, accepted that training data could in theory be a trade secret but said xAI hadn't shown its datasets or data-processing methods were any more sensitive than rivals'. He also called xAI's claim that no consumer could learn anything useful from a dataset summary a stretch. xAI appealed to the Ninth Circuit, and the denial of the injunction stays in place unless the appeals court says otherwise, so the law is in force while the case runs.

[Grok is struggling to turn Musk's reach into enterprise trust](https://startupfortune.com/grok-is-struggling-to-turn-musks-reach-into-enterprise-trust/)

Grok has wide consumer visibility, but Reuters' latest federal AI review shows limited government adoption despite near-free pricing. The story is a reminder that enterprise AI buyers value trust, compliance, and integration more than celebrity distribution. - [how to build enterprise trust for AI chatbots](https://startupfortune.com/grok-is-struggling-to-turn-musks-reach-into-enterprise-trust/) - [why government agencies prefer established AI vendors](https://startupfortune.com/grok-is-struggling-to-turn-musks-reach-into-enterprise-trust/)

That detail gets lost in the headlines. xAI isn't operating under a pause. Any obligation to publish a summary applies to it now, whatever the panel decides later.

## Why the Grok maker is the one suing

Frankly, it's an odd fight for xAI to pick as the loudest voice. A summary of training sources would tell the public, and plaintiffs' lawyers, a good deal about where Grok's training material came from, at a time when the company already faces scrutiny over the chatbot. Regulators and rivals read those disclosures too. Law firm commentary on the case has focused on the same exposure: a disclosure that looks harmless on a compliance checklist can become evidence in a copyright or privacy suit.

The other big labs haven't made this their fight. OpenAI, Anthropic and Google have not joined the challenge, and xAI is the lone company plaintiff. On the other side, MLex reported that AI researchers filed a brief urging the appeals court to uphold the law, so the transparency argument has its own backers.

If you're a developer shipping a model to California users, that split matters to you. A lab that complies quietly and a lab that sues over compliance are making opposite bets on how courts will treat disclosure rules.

## The precedent problem

The Ninth Circuit's answer will be one of the first appellate rulings on whether AI-specific transparency mandates survive the First Amendment. Rulings from that court carry weight across the western states, and other legislatures drafting disclosure bills will read the opinion closely. A win for xAI would hand every lab a template for challenging similar rules on speech grounds. A loss would tell states that requiring a public summary of training data is an ordinary business disclosure, much like a nutrition label.

It also lands in the middle of a federal fight. President Trump said at the APEC summit this week that the US won't let regulation stifle the AI industry, and xAI's argument fits neatly with that line. But a federal appeals court deciding a narrow constitutional question isn't Washington setting policy, and the panel's questions suggest the judges are focused on the statute's text and its practical reach, not on politics.

No decision date has been set. Amicus briefs were due in July, and the Ninth Circuit has not said when it will rule.

[Federal appeals court lets xAI keep fighting Minnesota's AI nudify ban](https://startupfortune.com/federal-appeals-court-lets-xai-keep-fighting-minnesotas-ai-nudify-ban/)

The 8th Circuit's one-sentence order blocks Minnesota from enforcing HF1606 against xAI while its First Amendment lawsuit against Attorney General Keith Ellison continues. A district judge had refused the same pause on September 4, saying xAI waited too long to sue. - [federal appeals court pauses Minnesota AI nudification law](https://startupfortune.com/federal-appeals-court-lets-xai-keep-fighting-minnesotas-ai-nudify-ban/) - [xAI First Amendment lawsuit against state nudify ban](https://startupfortune.com/federal-appeals-court-lets-xai-keep-fighting-minnesotas-ai-nudify-ban/)

**Also read:** [Trump tells APEC in Shenzhen he won't let regulation stifle the AI industry](https://startupfortune.com/trump-tells-apec-in-shenzhen-he-wont-let-regulation-stifle-the-ai-industry/) • [CoreWeave's McBee says GPUs beat buying back its 15% yield debt](https://startupfortune.com/coreweaves-mcbee-says-gpus-beat-buying-back-its-15-yield-debt/) • [Waymo pauses Bay Area robotaxi service after floods strand cars in San Francisco](https://startupfortune.com/waymo-pauses-bay-area-robotaxi-service-after-floods-strand-cars-in-san-francisco/)

*This article is posted in [AI News](https://startupfortune.com/category/ai/), check it out for more related stories.*

## Join the discussion

[Open in the community →](https://startupfortune.com/community/)

Almost there. Sign in and your reply posts straight away.
