Vdr – an attempt at a coredump handler secure by design (requesting review)

vdr stands for Voyage Data Recorder — the maritime equivalent of a flight data recorder. Ships record what happens during a voyage; vdr records what happens when a process crashes.

A modern, secure Linux core dump handler in Rust. Supports both pipe and socket modes.

This project was developed with AI assistance. The security claims below are written so that they can be verified independently of how the code was produced.

vdr runs as root, invoked by the kernel to capture core dumps — memory snapshots that may contain /etc/shadow hashes, API keys, private keys, and other credentials from crashed processes.

The primary attacker is a local unprivileged user who can:

• Crash arbitrary programs, including SUID binaries
• Control argv[0] and environment variables
• Fork processes and manipulate PID namespaces
• Trigger crashes in remote daemons (nginx, postgres workers), effectively gaining the same capability through crashed processes

The crashing process's memory image and /proc/pid/* snapshot are treated as potentially malicious input.

Access control

• No ACL attack surface — Core files are 0600 root-only viaO_CREAT|O_EXCL . Nosetfacl , nolibacl . Thefs.suid_dumpable=2 sysctl drop-in ships with vdrd to enable SUID/SGID core dumps; this is safe because 0600 root-only access control eliminates the CVE-2022-4415 class entirely (the CVE's mechanism was an ACL entry granting read access to the real UID — impossible without ACL code, and the 0600 root-only default covers other leak paths too).

Hot path safety

No DWARF in the hot path — vdr never parses DWARF in the recording path. A separate cold-path analysis tool (vdr-analyze ) is planned but not yet implemented. gimli's maintainer explicitly states it is not a security boundarygimli PR #889 ; libdwarf's design goal includes handling corrupted input (libdwarf README ), but its own vulnerability database lists 239 entries as of July 2026 (dwarfbug.html , latest: DW202605-008). Neither should be relied upon as a security boundary in the recording path. #

Streaming, bounded memory — Core data streams throughio::copy into a zstd encoder to disk, never fully loaded into RAM. Per-core limit: 2 GB. Executable size limit for build ID extraction: 64 MB. The systemd unit enforcesMemoryMax=256M ,TasksMax=4 , and a@system-service syscall filter.

Credential integrity (pipe mode)

• Race condition protection — vdr trusts the kernel's%d dumpable flag, not/proc/pid/auxv . A handler that reads auxv is vulnerable (CVE-2025-4598): an attacker can SIGKILL the crashing SUID process, wait for PID recycling, then fork a new non-SUID process to occupy the same PID — causing the handler to read the new process's auxv and misclassify the core dump as non-sensitive. vdr avoids this by not reading auxv.

Credential integrity (socket mode, Linux ≥ 6.16)

Kernel-tracked sensitivity — The kernel's judgment of whether a core dump is sensitive (PIDFD_COREDUMP_ROOT , set for SUID/SGID/ privileged processes) is stored in kernel data structures tied to the process ID, not the process's memory. It remains readable even after the crashing process is cleaned up. Individual credentials (UID/GID) frompidfd_info are time-sensitive: they require the crashing process to remain alive.core_pipe_limit > 0 makes the kernel block until vdrd closes the connection, keeping the crashing process alive during credential retrieval. #

Recursion prevention — vdrd marks itselfprctl(PR_SET_DUMPABLE, 0) to prevent recursive core dumps.

Socket authentication (socket mode) Four layers, all implemented:

- **L1** — Socket file permissions (0600 root:root), verified at startup
- **L2** —`PIDFD_COREDUMPED` kernel flag (see note below)
- **L3** —`SO_PEERPIDFD` (kernel-provided process reference, no race)

• L4 —pidfd_info credentials +PIDFD_COREDUMP_ROOT

On L2: PIDFD_COREDUMPED is set only by the kernel when a process crashes. No userspace API currently exists to set it directly, so a non-crashing process cannot fake this flag. However, this guarantee holds only because no such API exists today — it is not a structural impossibility. If a future kernel exposes a way to set the flag from userspace, L2 would weaken. The other layers (L1, L3, L4) would still apply, but L2 alone would no longer be sufficient.

Journal hygiene

• Minimal metadata —cmdline logging is currently not implemented. Environment variables and stack contents are not read. Ifcmdline logging is added in the future, it will use a whitelist-based scrub (only known-safe fields such asargv[0] basename and known valueless flags; everything else redacted). Operational fields currently logged: path, sizes, build ID, exe (truncated), comm, signal, hostname, pid, uid, gid, dumpable, core_limit.

Filesystem

• Symlink hardening — Storage directory is root-only 0700.O_CREAT|O_EXCL rejects symbolic links on the final path component.

Socket mode (Linux ≥ 6.16) currently supports only the @ (simple) coredump socket protocol. The @@ (request/ack handshake) protocol is not yet implemented.

vdr is licensed under the GNU General Public License version 2 only

([GPL-2.0-only](https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0.txt)).

SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0-only