The absurdly complicated circuitry for the 386 processor's registers

The Intel 386 processor, introduced in 1985, was the first 32-bit CPU in the x86 architecture and contains numerous registers that provide much faster storage than main memory. The processor's register implementation is surprisingly complex, using six different circuit types for its 30 registers instead of a standard design, with features like triple-porting for simultaneous reads and writes, interleaved bit storage, and support for 8, 16, or 32-bit accesses. This complexity arises partly from backward compatibility requirements, as registers like EAX can be accessed as 32-bit, 16-bit, or even 8-bit values.

The groundbreaking Intel 386 processor 1985 was the first 32-bit processor in the x86 architecture. Like most processors, the 386 contains numerous registers; registers are a key part of a processor because they provide storage that is much faster than main memory. The register set of the 386 includes general-purpose registers, index registers, and segment selectors, as well as registers with special functions for memory management and operating system implementation. In this blog post, I look at the silicon die of the 386 and explain how the processor implements its main registers. It turns out that the circuitry that implements the 386's registers is much more complicated than one would expect. For the 30 registers that I examine, instead of using a standard circuit, the 386 uses six different circuits, each one optimized for the particular characteristics of the register. For some registers, Intel squeezes register cells together to double the storage capacity. Other registers support accesses of 8, 16, or 32 bits at a time. Much of the register file is "triple-ported", allowing two registers to be read simultaneously while a value is written to a third register. Finally, I was surprised to find that registers don't store bits in order: the lower 16 bits of each register are interleaved, while the upper 16 bits are stored linearly. The photo below shows the 386's shiny fingernail-sized silicon die under a special metallurgical microscope. I've labeled the main functional blocks. For this post, the Data Unit in the lower left quadrant of the chip is the relevant component. It consists of the 32-bit arithmetic logic unit ALU along with the processor's main register bank highlighted in red at the bottom . The circuitry, called the datapath, can be viewed as the heart of the processor. The datapath is built with a regular structure: each register or ALU functional unit is a horizontal stripe of circuitry, forming the horizontal bands visible in the image. For the most part, this circuitry consists of a carefully optimized circuit copied 32 times, once for each bit of the processor. Each circuit for one bit is exactly the same width—60 µm—so the functional blocks can be stacked together like microscopic LEGO bricks. To link these circuits, metal bus lines run vertically through the datapath in groups of 32, allowing data to flow up and down through the blocks. Meanwhile, control lines run horizontally, enabling ALU operations or register reads and writes; the irregular circuitry on the right side of the Data Unit produces the signals for these control lines, activating the appropriate control lines for each instruction. The datapath is highly structured to maximize performance while minimizing its area on the die. Below, I'll look at how the registers are implemented according to this structure. A processor's registers are one of the most visible features of the processor architecture. The 386 processor contains 16 registers for use by application programmers, a small number by modern standards, but large enough for the time. The diagram below shows the eight 32-bit general-purpose registers. At the top are four registers called EAX, EBX, ECX, and EDX. Although these registers are 32-bit registers, they can also be treated as 16 or 8-bit registers for backward compatibility with earlier processors. For instance, the lower half of EAX can be accessed as the 16-bit register AX, while the bottom byte of EAX can be accessed as the 8-bit register AL. Moreover, bits 15-8 can also be accessed as an 8-bit register called AH. In other words, there are four different ways to access the EAX register, and similarly for the other three registers. As will be seen, these features complicate the implementation of the register set. The bottom half of the diagram shows that the 32-bit EBP, ESI, EDI, and ESP registers can also be treated as 16-bit registers BP, SI, DI, and SP. Unlike the previous registers, these ones cannot be treated as 8-bit registers. The 386 also has six segment registers that define the start of memory segments; these are 16-bit registers. The 16 application registers are rounded out by the status flags and instruction pointer EIP ; they are viewed as 32-bit registers, but their implementation is more complicated. The 386 also has numerous registers for operating system programming, but I won't discuss them here, since they are likely in other parts of the chip.1 Finally, the 386 has numerous temporary registers that are not visible to the programmer but are used by the microcode to perform complex instructions. The 386's registers are implemented with static RAM cells, a circuit that can hold one bit. These cells are arranged into a grid to provide multiple registers. Static RAM can be contrasted with the dynamic RAM that computers use for their main memory: dynamic RAM holds each bit in a tiny capacitor, while static RAM uses a faster but larger and more complicated circuit. Since main memory holds gigabytes of data, it uses dynamic RAM to provide dense and inexpensive storage. But the tradeoffs are different for registers: the storage capacity is small, but speed is of the essence. Thus, registers use the static RAM circuit that I'll explain below. The concept behind a static RAM cell is to connect two inverters into a loop. If an inverter has a "0" as input, it will output a "1", and vice versa. Thus, the inverter loop will be stable, with one inverter on and one inverter off, and each inverter supporting the other. Depending on which inverter is on, the circuit stores a 0 or a 1, as shown below. Thus, the pair of inverters provides one bit of memory. To be useful, however, the inverter loop needs a way to store a bit into it, as well as a way to read out the stored bit. To write a new value into the circuit, two signals are fed in, forcing the inverters to the desired new values. One inverter receives the new bit value, while the other inverter receives the complemented bit value. This may seem like a brute-force way to update the bit, but it works. The trick is that the inverters in the cell are small and weak, while the input signals are higher current, able to overpower the inverters.2 These signals are fed in through wiring called "bitlines"; the bitlines can also be used to read the value stored in the cell. To control access to the register, the bitlines are connected to the inverters through pass transistors, which act as switches to control access to the inverter loop.3 When the pass transistors are on, the signals on the write lines can pass through to the inverters. But when the pass transistors are off, the inverters are isolated from the write lines. The pass transistors are turned on by a control signal, called a "wordline" since it controls access to a word of storage in the register. Since each inverter is constructed from two transistors, the circuit above consists of six transistors—thus this circuit is called a "6T" cell. The 6T cell uses the same bitlines for reading and writing, so you can't read and write to registers simultaneously. But adding two transistors creates an "8T" circuit that lets you read from one register and write to another register at the same time. In technical terms, the register file is two-ported. In the 8T schematic below, the two additional transistors G and H are used for reading. Transistor G buffers the cell's value; it turns on if the inverter output is high, pulling the read output bitline low.4 Transistor H is a pass transistor that blocks this signal until a read is performed on this register; it is controlled by a read wordline. Note that there are two bitlines for writing as before along with one bitline for reading. To construct registers or memory , a grid is constructed from these cells. Each row corresponds to a register, while each column corresponds to a bit position. The horizontal lines are the wordlines, selecting which word to access, while the vertical lines are the bitlines, passing bits in or out of the registers. For a write, the vertical bitlines provide the 32 bits along with their complements . For a read, the vertical bitlines receive the 32 bits from the register. A wordline is activated to read or write the selected register. To summarize: each row is a register, data flows vertically, and control signals flow horizontally. The die photo below zooms in on the register circuitry in the lower left corner of the 386 processor. You can see the arrangement of storage cells into a grid, but note that the pattern changes from row to row. This circuitry implements 30 registers: 22 of the registers hold 32 bits, while the bottom ones are 16-bit registers. By studying the die, I determined that there are six different register circuits, which I've arbitrarily labeled a to f . In this section, I'll describe these six types of registers. I'll start at the bottom with the simplest circuit: eight 16-bit registers that I'm calling type f . You can see a "notch" on the left side of the register file because these registers are half the width of the other registers 16 bits versus 32 bits . These registers are implemented with the 8T circuit described earlier, making them dual ported: one register can be read while another register is written. As described earlier, three vertical bus lines pass through each bit: one bitline for reading and two bitlines with opposite polarity for writing. Each register has two control lines wordlines : one to select a register for reading and another to select a register for writing. The photo below shows how four cells of type f are implemented on the chip. In this image, the chip's two metal layers have been removed along with most of the polysilicon wiring, showing the underlying silicon. The dark outlines indicate regions of doped silicon, while the stripes across the doped region correspond to transistor gates. I've labeled each transistor with a letter corresponding to the earlier schematic. Observe that the layout of the bottom half is a mirrored copy of the upper half, saving a bit of space. The left and right sides are approximately mirrored; the irregular shape allows separate read and wite wordlines to control the left and right halves without colliding. The 386's register file and datapath are designed with 60 µm of width assigned to each bit. However, the register circuit above is unusual: the image above is 60 µm wide but there are two register cells side-by-side. That is, the circuit crams two bits in 60 µm of width, rather than one. Thus, this dense layout implements two registers per row with interleaved bits , providing twice the density of the other register circuits. If you're curious to know how the transistors above are connected, the schematic below shows how the physical arrangement of the transistors above corresponds to two of the 8T memory cells described earlier. Since the 386 has two overlapping layers of metal, it is very hard to interpret a die photo with the metal layers. But see my earlier article if you want these photos. Above the type f registers are 10 registers of type e , occupying five rows of cells. These registers are the same 8T implementation as before, but these registers are 32 bits wide instead of 16. Thus, the register takes up the full width of the datapath, unlike the previous registers. As before, the double-density circuit implements two registers per row. The silicon layout is identical apart from being 32 bits wide instead of 16 , so I'm not including a photo. Above those registers are four d registers, which are more complex. They are triple-ported registers, so one register can be written while two other registers are read. This is useful for ALU operations, for instance, since two values can be added and the result written back at the same time. To support reading a second register, another vertical bus line is added for each bit. Each cell has two more transistors to connect the cell to