Tavily vs Google search API: which should my AI agent use? A developer-run benchmark compared Tavily, SerpApi and cloro as search backends for AI agents across SimpleQA Verified, FreshQA and FRAMES, finding Tavily fastest at a 2.00s median search time but weakest on multi-hop questions (48.4% versus 80.2% for cloro and 77.4% for SerpApi). In a separate 500-query test, 80% of Google's top-10 domains also appeared in Tavily's results, though rank correlation was near zero, and removing Google's AI Overview dropped accuracy on 100 factual questions from 99% to 86%. Tavily cost $5.45 per 1,000 correct factual answers on its Growth plan, against $1.98 for cloro and $15.08 for SerpApi. Use Tavily when your AI agent needs fast, model-ready text from the web, and use a Google search API when the agent must see what Google shows: the ranking order, the AI Overview and People Also Ask. For a new project in 2026, "Google search API" means a third-party Google SERP API or Gemini's Grounding with Google Search, because Google's own Custom Search JSON API https://developers.google.com/custom-search/v1/overview is closed to new customers and ends on January 1, 2027. | | Tavily Search API | Google SERP API | Gemini Grounding with Google Search | |---|---|---|---| | Index | Tavily's own, aggregated and reranked | The live Google.com page | Google Search, through a Gemini model | | Per result | url , title , content , score | position , title , link , snippet | No result list: the answer, the queries the model ran and a URL and title per citation | | Extra blocks | Optional generated answer | Google's AI Overview, People Also Ask | None | | Full page text | Yes, with include raw content | No | No | | Median search time | 2.00 s | 7.96 s and 8.20 s | Not measured | | Free allowance | 1,000 credits a month | 250 searches a month SerpApi , 500 credits a month cloro | 5,000 search queries a month on Gemini 3 and newer | | Live price per 1,000 | $8 pay as you go, $5 on Growth | $25 on SerpApi Starter, $1.20 on cloro Hobby $2.00 with the AI Overview | $14 per 1,000 search queries, plus tokens | | Rate limit | 100 requests a minute free, 1,000 with pay as you go | By plan | By plan | Sources: Tavily search docs https://docs.tavily.com/documentation/api-reference/endpoint/search , Tavily credits https://docs.tavily.com/documentation/api-credits , Tavily rate limits https://docs.tavily.com/documentation/rate-limits , SerpApi pricing https://serpapi.com/pricing , Gemini API pricing https://aistudio.google.com/docs/pricing and grounding docs https://aistudio.google.com/docs/google-search , all read on November 16, 2026. The index row matters less than it looks. In a 500-query test, 80% of Google's top 10 domains also appeared in Tavily's results, and Google's first domain was in Tavily's top 10 on 92% of queries. The order was different: the top 3 domains overlapped at 0.25, and the rank correlation was near zero. Google also showed an AI Overview on 64% of those queries and People Also Ask on 77%, and Tavily returns neither. So Tavily gives the agent much of Google's sources in its own order, and leaves out the blocks Google adds on top. The benchmark gave each API the question text as its query, one search and 10 results. One model answered from those results alone, and a second model graded each answer against the answer key. | API | Short factual SimpleQA Verified, 1,000 | Recent events FreshQA, 358 | Multi-hop FRAMES, 824 | $ per 1,000 correct factual answers | Median search time | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Tavily | 91.8% | 81.8% | 48.4% | $5.45 | 2.00 s | | SerpApi | 94.7% | 88.5% | 77.4% | $15.08 | 8.20 s | | cloro | 96.9% | 88.3% | 80.2% | $1.98 | 7.96 s | Two causes explain most of the multi-hop gap. First, the four APIs with their own index, Tavily among them, replied "not found" on 151 to 295 of the 824 questions each, because their 10 results did not hold every fact the question needs. For an agent, each "not found" is a second search or a failed task. Second, the AI Overview does a large part of the work: with the same saved Google results and the AI Overview removed, accuracy on 100 factual questions fell from 99% to 86%. The benchmark measures one search per question with no page fetch. An agent that searches three times and reads pages can close part of the gap, at the cost of more calls and more tokens. It also priced Tavily on its Growth plan; pay as you go, the cost per correct answer is higher. | Your agent | Use | |---|---| | A chat assistant that must answer in under 3 seconds | Tavily | | Reads whole pages before it answers, for RAG or research | Tavily, with include raw content or its Extract endpoint | | Answers multi-hop questions in the background or in batches | A Google SERP API with the AI Overview | | Checks rankings, AI Overview citations or People Also Ask | A Google SERP API. Tavily has no Google order and no Google blocks | | Runs on Gemini and only needs a cited answer | Grounding with Google Search | | Built from LangChain or LangGraph examples | Tavily is already in the docs; a SERP API is one more tool function | Tavily is the sound default when speed and page text matter more than Google's view. It is also simpler to start: 1,000 free credits a month and a LangChain integration. Pick the Google SERP API when the question is hard, or when the answer must match what a person sees on Google. Yes. Give the agent the fast search as its default tool and Google as a second tool, called when the first one does not find the answer: php import os, requests def fast search q: str - list dict : r = requests.post "https://api.tavily.com/search", headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {os.environ 'TAVILY API KEY' }"}, json={"query": q, "max results": 5}, timeout=30, return {"url": x "url" , "text": x "content" } for x in r.json "results" def google search q: str - dict: r = requests.post "https://api.cloro.dev/v1/monitor/google", headers={"Authorization": f"Bearer {os.environ 'SERP API KEY' }"}, json={"query": q, "country": "US", "include": {"aioverview": True}}, timeout=120, res = r.json "result" return { "ai overview": res.get "aioverview" or {} .get "text" , "results": {"url": x "link" , "text": x "snippet" } for x in res "organicResults" :5 , } Two details from the benchmark apply to the second tool. The top 5 results scored the same as the top 10 with 35% fewer tokens, and titles and URLs added no accuracy, so pass the AI Overview and the snippets. Keep the URLs only if the agent must cite its sources. Set the timeout high: a synchronous Google request takes several seconds. The synchronous call above, with the AI Overview, costs 7 credits, which is $2.80 per 1,000 on cloro's Hobby plan. The $2.00 in the table is the async rate. For hundreds of queries on a schedule, an async endpoint with a webhook is cheaper and removes the wait. This comparison is published by cloro, which sells one of the Google SERP APIs in it and also ran the benchmark. The harness, the questions, the settings and every graded answer are public in the benchmark repo https://github.com/cloro-dev/web-search-api-benchmark , so the rows for its own API can be checked or run again with other keys. The reader model was gpt-5.6-luna and the grader was gpt-5.6-sol . The accuracy, cost and latency figures are copied from the repo without recomputing. The overlap figures come from a separate 500-query run through Tavily and live Google results on the same day, written up in Tavily vs Google Search: How Much SERP Do You See? https://cloro.dev/blog/tavily-vs-google-search/ . Tavily, SerpApi and Gemini prices and limits come from their own pages, linked above and read on November 16, 2026. Prices change, so open the page before you commit.