{"slug": "surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review", "title": "Surveillance Pricing Warrants Further Review", "summary": "The Federal Trade Commission launched an inquiry in October ordering major airlines, ride-sharing companies and food delivery services to detail how they set personalized prices and what consumer data they collect, following an Aug. 19 enforcement proposal statement on personalized pricing. FTC Chairman Andrew N. Ferguson said \"Consumers deserve to know whether companies use their web surfing habits or other personal data to estimate the highest price they can charge each consumer,\" while the Consumer Federation of America, whose AI and data privacy director Ben Winters called surveillance pricing \"absolutely a violation of people's privacy,\" urged the commission in a September letter to prohibit the practice. The FTC said Congress has not granted it authority to ban all forms of surveillance pricing but that it will pursue deceptive or unfair personalized pricing tactics violating Section 5 of the FTC Act.", "body_md": "### JEFFREY ALEXANDER\n\nCommunity Sentinel\n\nConsumer advocates and the [Federal Trade Commission](https://www.ftc.gov/) (FTC) continue studies on surveillance pricing, the practice of leveraging consumer data to create individualized product pricing in digital landscapes. However, consumer advocates and data privacy experts agree that this practice violates data privacy, creates unfair business practices, and, with little to no transparency, leaves consumers and advocates facing challenges in fully understanding how data is collected and used when determining prices for products and services.\n\nBen Winters, director of AI and data privacy with the [Consumer Federation of America](https://consumerfed.org/) (CFA), a consumer advocacy and action organization, defined surveillance pricing as, “When a business sets a price for people based on their inferred willingness to pay for a good or service utilizing sophisticated algorithms.” This often results in consumers paying contrasting price points for the same product or service based on compiled data that may include zip code, date of birth, and even family income. The CFA drafted an [explanatory report on the practice of surveillance pricing](https://consumerfed.org/media/dxspkt4h/explaining-surveillance-pricing-and-other-data-driven-pricing-practices-august-20-2026.pdf) and its negative impacts on consumers.\n\n## **CFA and FTC’s response**\n\n“This is absolutely a violation of people’s privacy. For the most part, an individual cannot know in real-time if they are being taken advantage of,” said Winters. “In fact, it is one of the most pernicious aspects of surveillance pricing: a consumer doesn’t know what data is being used to determine a price of a promotional offering, how they got that data, and whether it is having a positive or negative impact.”\n\nThe Consumer Federation of America wrote a letter to the FTC in September, stating the commission does have the authority to prohibit the discriminatory practice of surveillance pricing and urged it to exercise its power to properly monitor and enforce sanctions.\n\nThe FTC launched an inquiry in October, ordering top airline companies, ride-sharing companies, and food delivery services to provide the commission with detailed information and processes on how personalized pricing is determined and what personal data is collected from consumers.\n\n“Consumers deserve to know whether companies use their web surfing habits or other personal data to estimate the highest price they can charge each consumer. Workers also deserve to know if their compensation is affected by how companies use their personal data,” [commented](https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2026/10/ftc-launches-personalized-pricing-compensation-inquiry) FTC Chairman Andrew N. Ferguson.\n\nThis inquiry followed the FTC’s Aug. 19 [enforcement proposal statement](https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/p034101-ftc-enforcement-policy-statement-re-personalized-pricing-proposed-for-public-comment.pdf) regarding personalized pricing. The commission cited growing public concern and, in its statement, said “Congress and state legislatures are increasingly concerned that the massive amount of data collected and generated when consumers use modern technology is making it possible for merchants to personalize prices for goods and services that traditionally did not vary from person to person. American consumers therefore reasonably expect it will not be any different for them than it will be for their friends or neighbors.”\n\nDespite the FTC’s inquiry, the commission said Congress has not given them the authority to prohibit all forms of surveillance pricing but said it would actively pursue deceptive or unfair personalized pricing tactics that violate [Section 5 of the FTC Act](https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/statement-enforcement-principles-regarding-unfair-methods-competition-under-section-5-ftc-act).\n\nWinters said the FTC’s actions are “a positive first step.” “Their rule-making shows an intention to require transparency only in this type of pricing. We’re not quite sure how they will end up, but hopefully they expand it in the rule-making processes,” he said.\n\n## **Consumers unaware of what data is being collected**\n\nSydney Saubestre, senior policy analyst and data privacy expert with the [Center for Democracy & Technology](https://cdt.org/) (CDT), continues studying surveillance pricing processes and the extent of data collection of consumers. She believes the lack of a comprehensive, federal data privacy law continues to enable the retail and technology industries to engage in data privacy violations with limited accountability.\n\n“I think surveillance pricing is an unfair practice. We had one report of an individual pricing a product while in Target and comparing the same product outside the same store on their app and found different pricing. We have been very concerned about data privacy, and we want people to understand their privacy matters, and they do have rights as consumers,” said Saubestre.\n\nShe noted the practice of surveillance pricing lacks transparency, making it challenging for consumer advocates and individuals to clearly identify in real time when data privacy violations occur; however, research has proved that this highly variable practice has collected sensitive data from consumers, resulting in individuals within identified zip codes paying higher prices for products than other individuals seeking to purchase the same item.\n\n“We have seen retail industry responses of ‘that’s capitalism’ and supply and demand, but this is not a transparent and level playing field,” said Saubestre. “Both sides do not have equal access to pertinent information, and individuals do not know the full details of this practice.”\n\n[Consumer Reports](https://www.consumerreports.org/) studied data collection and its impact on consumers, leading to a collaborative investigatory study with [Groundwork Collaborative](https://groundworkcollaborative.org/) into Instacart, a grocery delivery and pickup platform connecting personal grocery shoppers with online customers. Consumer Reports alleged the AI-driven service utilized consumer data to set individualized product pricing that sharply contrasted with other consumers purchasing the same exact products. The algorithmic pricing resulted in needlessly high costs to consumers. A Consumer Reports survey of over 2,000 adults conducted in 2025 showed 72 percent of individuals who used Instacart did not want the company charging different users different prices for any reason.\n\nConsumer Reports used [Instacart](https://www.instacart.com/) for its survey after concluding the platform was the most widely used grocery delivery app service. The investigation highlighted that some product prices varied from as little as seven cents per item to $2.56 per item. [Consumer Reports said that after its joint investigation](https://www.consumerreports.org/money/questionable-business-practices/instacart-stops-ai-pricing-experiments-a1176475852/) with Groundwork Collaborative, [Instacart announced](https://company.instacart.com/updates/ending-item-price-tests-on-instacart) on Dec. 22, 2025, it would end AI-driven grocery pricing on its platform.\n\n“We understand that the tests we ran with a small number of retail partners that resulted in different prices for the same item at the same store missed the mark for some customers. At a time when families are working exceptionally hard to stretch every grocery dollar, those tests raised concerns, leaving some people questioning the prices they see on Instacart. That’s not okay, especially for a company built on trust, transparency, and affordability,” [commented Instacart](https://company.instacart.com/updates/ending-item-price-tests-on-instacart).\n\n## **Proposed legislation**\n\nState officials and legislators are monitoring surveillance pricing tactics, and proposed legislation has been introduced in Maryland, Connecticut, New Jersey, New York, and California. The majority of these legislative efforts were not adopted into state law, but New York successfully adopted Assembly Bill A3008 into its Article 22-A law: Protection from Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts and Practices.\n\nNew York Gov. Kathy Hochul signed [A3008](https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2025/A3008C) on May 9, 2025, making surveillance pricing a deceptive act to knowingly offer “personalized algorithmic pricing using consumer data specific to a particular individual” unless the personalized algorithmic price contains a disclosure stating: “This price was set by an algorithm using your personal data.”\n\nNew York consumer advocates and lawmakers continued calling for more stringent regulations of surveillance pricing, resulting in the state legislature passing the One Fair Price Act in June. The legislation, championed by New York State Attorney General Letitia James, would ban surveillance pricing and currently awaits Gov. Hochul’s signature. “When this bill becomes law, shoppers will be able to trust that the price they are paying is a fair price, not one dictated by their web browsing history, income, race, or zip code. I am grateful to the bill sponsors and our broad coalition for their partnership in protecting New York consumers,” [commented](https://ag.ny.gov/press-release/2026/attorney-general-james-applauds-passage-legislation-protect-new-yorkers) James.\n\n[Embed from Getty Images](https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/1659948580)\n\nCalifornia attempted to pass legislation [sponsored by Assemblymember Chris Ward](https://calmatters.digitaldemocracy.org/hearings/259600?t=1415&f=68514a0cd6f42ba1374a6fad2b263a7b) (D-San Diego) that would outright ban surveillance pricing, but the bill died in the state assembly in September, despite the California Senate voting 22-14 to adopt and implement a ban. If California successfully adopted and implemented AB 2564, the state, under the authority of its attorney general, would be able to impose fines of $2,000 per violation for businesses engaging in surveillance pricing tactics. Ward [commented](https://ward.asmdc.org/press-releases/20260223-assemblymember-ward-reintroduces-legislation-ban-surveillance-pricing) that new consumer protections are paramount when working to counter rising costs for all consumer goods and services across the nation.\n\n“At a time when prices for necessities are rising across the board, it is more critical than ever to ensure that people are not being unfairly charged higher prices due to their actual or perceived characteristics,” said Assemblymember Ward. “The right to fair pricing should not be a privilege for the few but a fundamental protection for all. One product, one price.”\n\n## **Recommendations**\n\nThe CDT filed comments to the FTC, providing a detailed outline of recommendations on how to respond to surveillance pricing. Among its recommendations, the CDT’s desired outcome consists of clearly stating surveillance pricing is unfair, whether or not a seller discloses the practice, treating the collection, purchase, retention, and sale of personal data for the express purpose of creating individualized prices as unfair standing alone, and committing to making full and robust use of the authority it already has, rather than waiting for legislation.\n\n“I believe all this can be solved with a comprehensive, federal data privacy law because it cuts off the input,; limits the collection of personal data, and eliminates the level of detail a company uses to track behavior and habits,” said Saubestre.\n\nShe said consumers continue to express concern about the practice of surveillance pricing, which gives greater visibility to data privacy advocacy efforts. “Individuals may not always realize the severity and scope of data privacy violations, but with the practice of surveillance pricing, they can quickly see an impact because it’s financially based. People can feel detached from personal data privacy issues, but surveillance pricing is a perfect example of tying in the importance of data privacy protection and consumer advocacy.”\n\nData privacy advocates are still calling for a comprehensive, federal data privacy law despite continued attempts by states introducing legislation to monitor and implement protections against surveillance pricing. New York’s One Fair Price Act may currently stand as the strongest state legislation confronting and banning surveillance pricing, but the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a data privacy advocacy organization, has reinforced its call for a federal law to outright ban surveillance pricing and implement data privacy protections with stricter enforcement mechanisms.\n\n“Consumers should be alarmed by this practice,” said Chao Jun Liu, senior legislative associate with EFF. He warned tech industry lobbyists, retailers, and data brokerage firms strongly oppose any regulatory efforts promoting more comprehensive data privacy laws and more transparency of surveillance pricing tactics. “There’s a lot of money behind these industries designed to extract as much money as possible from individuals. They’re working to monopolize market dominance and really limit consumer choice.”\n\nHe noted companies actively engaging in surveillance pricing work to obfuscate facts surrounding what the actual, true base price of a product or service is and then push a discount to consumers, attempting to trigger a sale that may be based on an unfair market price.\n\n“Business practices like surveillance pricing are really an asymmetry of information. Companies have easy access to a vast amount of data, which can be invasive, while consumers have little understanding of how their data is collected, let alone used. Our ideal outcome at EFF would be a ban on this practice,” said Liu.", "url": "https://wpnews.pro/news/surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review", "canonical_source": "https://communitysentinel.media/2026/11/18/surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review/", "published_at": "2026-11-19 23:22:55+00:00", "updated_at": "2026-11-19 23:44:42.498583+00:00", "lang": "en", "topics": ["ai-policy", "ai-ethics"], "entities": ["Federal Trade Commission", "Consumer Federation of America", "Ben Winters", "Andrew N. Ferguson", "Section 5 of the FTC Act"], "also_reported_by": [], "takeaway": null, "recommendation": null, "alternates": {"html": "https://wpnews.pro/news/surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review", "markdown": "https://wpnews.pro/news/surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review.md", "text": "https://wpnews.pro/news/surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review.txt", "jsonld": "https://wpnews.pro/news/surveillance-pricing-warrants-further-review.jsonld"}}