{"slug": "show-hn-pip-your-git-history-puts-you-on-a-performance-improvement-plan", "title": "Show HN: Pip – Your Git history puts you on a Performance Improvement Plan", "summary": "A developer released Pip, a single-file Python tool installed via `pip install on-a-pip` that reads a local git history and issues a manager-style performance review of the commit record, grading Communication, Reliability, Follow-through, Judgment and Consistency and generating a 30-day improvement plan from the three weakest categories. Pip uses no AI, models or uploads, runs plain arithmetic on the local repository, and can also clone and grade public projects by GitHub shorthand or git URL; in the author's example, the creator of Requests grades out at a D with a Night Owl award across 3,148 commits. The tool's author states it is a novelty that is not for employment decisions because it grades a commit record, not a person.", "body_md": "Every tool reviews your code. **PIP reviews the programmer.**\n\nNo AI, no models, no uploads: PIP is one Python file of plain arithmetic that reads your\nlocal git history and issues a formal manager-style performance review of the person who\nwrote it. Grades, evidence, awards, and a 30-day improvement plan. It is a novelty that\ntakes its evidence seriously, and it is **not for employment decisions**: it grades a\ncommit record, not a person, and it reads best when the reader is the author.\n\nEvery developer keeps a work diary without knowing it: their git history. Every change is in there, with a timestamp and a little note that was supposed to explain it. PIP reads that record, locally, on your own machine, and issues a formal manager-style performance review. With evidence.\n\n```\npip install on-a-pip\n```\n\nThen, inside any git repository:\n\n```\non-a-pip\n```\n\nOr see how a famous project's record grades out, straight from the internet:\n\n```\non-a-pip psf/requests                      # GitHub shorthand\non-a-pip https://github.com/psf/requests    # any git URL\non-a-pip psf/requests --leaderboard        # rank the whole team\n```\n\nPIP clones the repo into a temp folder, reviews it, and deletes the clone when it is done (`--keep` keeps it, `--shallow 500` fetches only recent history on huge repos). Reviewing a famous project is an education: the creator of Requests, 3,148 commits deep, grades out at a D with a Night Owl award. The record is the record.\n\n```\n  PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT PLAN  -  Dev Example\n  pip-sample  |  8 commits reviewed  |  2025-10-14 to 2026-11-08\n  --------------------------------------------------------------\n  Communication    F    32.5  ######\n  Reliability      C    64.4  ############\n  Follow-through   B    84.3  ################\n  Judgment         B    83.8  #################\n  Consistency      D    43.0  ########\n  --------------------------------------------------------------\n  OVERALL          C    61.6\n  Meets some expectations. There is a conversation to be had.\n```\n\n(That is a real review of a deliberately terrible sample history. Yours will be different. Possibly worse.)\n\n- **Communication.** How many of your commit messages actually say anything. \"stuff\", \"wip\" and \"asdf\" are entered into the record, quoted back at you.\n- **Reliability.** Commits between 10pm and 5am. Commits shipped Friday after 4pm. Reverts. Chains of commits that start with \"fix\".\n- **Follow-through.** The TODOs still sitting in your code, and how old the oldest one is. A TODO that has been waiting 400 days has seniority.\n- **Judgment.** The spots labelled \"temporary\", \"hack\" or \"workaround\", and how long the oldest one has been load-bearing.\n- **Consistency.** Active days versus silent stretches, longest streak, longest disappearance.\n\nThen it does what any good PIP does: it writes you a **30-day improvement plan**, generated from your three weakest categories, and signs off with the only appeal process that has ever worked: improve the record.\n\nGrades are the paperwork. Awards are the part people post. PIP reads your habits and hands out titles, each one earned by the record:\n\n- **Night Owl** - a quarter or more of your commits land between 10pm and 5am\n- **Friday Gambler** - repeated Friday-after-4pm shipping\n- **Demolitionist** - you delete more than you add, at scale\n- **The Ghost** - a 60+ day disappearance, then a casual return\n- **Fossil Keeper** - a TODO old enough to qualify for the pension plan\n- **Surgeon** ,**Streak Keeper** ,**Open Book** ,**Strong Silent Type** ,**Chaos Agent** ,**Weekend Warrior** ,**Colourful Commentator**\n- **Marathon Day** (15+ commits in one day),**The Purge** (a single commit deleting 1,000+ lines),**Polyglot** (real churn in 5+ languages),**Old Faithful** (3+ years on one codebase),**Phoenix** (a long disappearance followed by a genuine comeback)\n\nIt also names your **nemesis file** (the one with the most churn in your history) and your largest single commit, because management did the reading.\n\n```\non-a-pip --persona brutal       # the startup CTO\non-a-pip --persona supportive   # the kind lead\non-a-pip --persona passive      # the passive-aggressive middle manager\non-a-pip --persona corporate    # the default. HR is present.\n```\n\nThe evidence never changes. The tone absolutely does.\n\n```\non-a-pip ~/some/repo --md review.md --html card.html --svg card.svg --badge badge.svg\non-a-pip --author \"your name\"     # review one author (default: the most prolific)\non-a-pip --days 90                # just the last 90 days of history\non-a-pip --since 2026-01-01 --until 2026-03-31   # or a calendar window\non-a-pip --reference letter.md    # also write a letter of reference, based on the grade\non-a-pip --vs \"Alice\" \"Bob\"       # head to head: two authors, one repo, one winner\non-a-pip --scan ~/projects        # review the top author of every repo in a folder\non-a-pip --quarter                # the quarterly ritual: last 90 days, compared to your last review\non-a-pip --year 2026              # PIP Wrapped: your year in commits, as a shareable edition\non-a-pip --outdir ./my-review     # write every artifact at once: review, cards, badge, reference, JSON\non-a-pip --fail-below B           # exit code 3 if the grade is worse than B (a CI gate, serious or otherwise)\non-a-pip --history                # your grade trend across every saved review of this repo\non-a-pip --coach                  # coaching mode: a four-week drill plan instead of a verdict\non-a-pip --blame app.py           # a performance review for one file: every commit that touched it\non-a-pip --org psf                # org board: the top author of a GitHub user's public repos\non-a-pip --share card.svg         # the 1200x630 share card, sized for social posts\non-a-pip --tz Europe/Berlin       # grade in your timezone, not the server's\non-a-pip --branch main --path src # narrow the record: one branch, one corner of the tree\non-a-pip --persona-file noir.json # bring your own manager: a custom persona pack\non-a-pip --leaderboard            # review every author in the repo and rank them\non-a-pip psf/requests               # or skip the local part entirely: any public repo by URL\non-a-pip --json                   # machine-readable review\n```\n\n- The terminal summary above, now with awards, and a progress line comparing you to your last review (PIP remembers, locally).\n- A full formal review in Markdown: per-category evidence, management notes, additional findings, awards, the plan, the sign-off.\n- Shareable **report cards** in HTML and**SVG** (the SVG embeds straight into a README), plus a small**grade badge** for your profile.\n- A **leaderboard mode** for shared repos. Run it on your team. We accept no responsibility for the standup that follows.\n- A **letter of reference** (`--reference` ), written by management in the tone your grade deserves. A grades get a glowing letter. F grades get a short one.\n- Career stats in every review: busiest day ever, monthly activity sparkline, languages ranked by churn. Identities are grouped by email, so one person under two names is one employee, and two people sharing a name stay two rows.\n- **Head-to-head mode** (`--vs` ): two authors compared category by category, with a declared winner and consequences for the loser.\n- **Folder scan** (`--scan` ): point PIP at a directory of projects and get one ranked board of every repo's top author.\n- **Mailmap support:** if the repo has a`.mailmap` , PIP honors it, so identity merging follows the project's own records.\n- **PIP Wrapped** (`--year` ): the year-in-commits edition, with its own dark Wrapped card: busiest month, top award, your catchphrase.\n- **Hall of fame stats:** longest commit message (the novel), shortest (the haiku), and your catchphrase, the word your subjects cannot stop using.\n- Report cards chart your commits per month; `--outdir` writes the full artifact set in one run;`--fail-below` turns a grade into a CI gate.\n- **History** (`--history` ): every review is saved locally, so your grade becomes a trend line with bars, not a one-off verdict.\n- **Coaching mode** (`--coach` ): four weeks of drills aimed at your three weakest categories, each with a measurable check.\n- **File reviews** (`--blame` ): one file, every commit that ever touched it, formally reviewed.\n- **Repo config:** a`.pip.toml` in the repo root can set`persona` and`fail_below` once for the whole team; the command line still wins.\n- 21 awards now, including The Archaeologist (revives files untouched for a year), Merge Goblin, Lone Wolf, and Rubber Duck (commit bodies longer than some READMEs).\n- **Org boards** (`--org` ): point PIP at any GitHub user and get one ranked board across their public repos, with an Org MVP.\n- **Fair records by default:** bot authors (dependabot and friends) are excluded unless you ask for them with`--include-bots` ; Co-authored-by trailers earn shared credit; lockfiles and minified files do not count as churn; squash-merge-heavy histories carry an authorship note saying the grade belongs to whoever pressed the merge button.\n- **Boards export:**`--csv` prints leaderboard, scan, and org boards as CSV;`--json` covers every mode.\n- **Pair stats:** the leaderboard now names the pair most in sync, ranked by shared active days.\n- **Persona packs:** six managers built in (Corporate, Startup CTO, Supportive Lead, Passive-Aggressive Middle Manager, Pirate Captain, Noir Detective), and`--persona-file` loads your own from a small JSON pack. Two sample packs live in`personas/` .\n- A scheduled monthly profile-review Action example lives in `examples/` .\n\nThe report card:\n\nThe 1200x630 share card (`--share`):\n\nPIP Wrapped, the year in commits (`--year`):\n\nThe full written review is in [examples/sample-review.md](https://github.com/littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip/blob/main/examples/sample-review.md), and a rendered HTML card in [examples/report-card-decksmith.html](https://github.com/littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip/blob/main/examples/report-card-decksmith.html). The demo GIF above is rendered from the tool's real output by [tools/make_demo_gif.py](https://github.com/littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip/blob/main/tools/make_demo_gif.py).\n\nFamous projects, formally reviewed: [the PIP Gallery](https://github.com/littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip/blob/main/gallery) has real report cards and\nleaderboards for Requests, Flask, Express, and normalize.css, all generated by PIP itself.\n\nSample outputs live in [`examples/`](https://github.com/littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip/blob/main/examples): a full sample review, sample report cards, a badge, and a real report card generated from the Decksmith repository.\n\n```\non-a-pip --readme\n```\n\nRun inside your repo, this writes `pip-card.svg` and `pip-badge.svg` and adds a marked **My PIP review** section to your README (the one at the bottom of this README is PIP reviewing this repo). Re-run it any time to refresh the grade.\n\nTo keep it current automatically, use the GitHub Action in your workflow:\n\n```\nname: pip-review\non:\n  push:\n    branches: [main]\npermissions:\n  contents: write\njobs:\n  review:\n    runs-on: ubuntu-latest\n    steps:\n      - uses: actions/checkout@v4\n        with:\n          fetch-depth: 0\n      - uses: littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip@main\n```\n\nEvery push gets a fresh review, committed by the bot. Your README becomes a living performance record, which is either motivating or a threat, depending on your habits.\n\nPIP runs `git log`, `git grep` and `git blame` on your machine and nothing else. No network, no account, no API key, no telemetry, pure Python standard library. Your history is embarrassing enough without uploading it somewhere.\n\n- Python 3.9+\n- git, on your PATH\n\n- The package is called `on-a-pip` because PyPI rejected`pip-pip` as too similar to`pip` itself, which is fair: you do not get to out-pip pip. The tool was going to be`pip install pip-pip` . Now you install the news that you are on one.\n- Grades are deterministic: same history, same review. The formulas are plain arithmetic in one file, `pip_pip.py` , if you want to argue with them.\n- PIP reviews the most prolific author in the repo by default. Use `--author` in shared repos.\n\nMIT. Built by [Ghost Developer Studio](https://ghostdeveloperstudio.com).\n\n**Grade: B (76/100)** · 21 commits reviewed · Top award: Night Owl · Reviewed 2026-11-19\n\n*This section is maintained by [PIP](https://pypi.org/project/on-a-pip/) (`on-a-pip --readme`). The record speaks for itself.*", "url": "https://wpnews.pro/news/show-hn-pip-your-git-history-puts-you-on-a-performance-improvement-plan", "canonical_source": "https://github.com/littlestjames82-sys/pip-pip", "published_at": "2026-11-19 04:36:25+00:00", "updated_at": "2026-11-19 04:44:21.599528+00:00", "lang": "en", "topics": ["developer-tools"], "entities": ["Pip", "on-a-pip", "Requests", "GitHub", "Python"], "also_reported_by": [], "takeaway": "Pip is a single Python file that scores a git history on five categories — Communication, Reliability, Follow-through, Judgment and Consistency — and builds a 30-day plan from the three lowest, with no AI or uploads.", "recommendation": null, "alternates": {"html": "https://wpnews.pro/news/show-hn-pip-your-git-history-puts-you-on-a-performance-improvement-plan", "markdown": "https://wpnews.pro/news/show-hn-pip-your-git-history-puts-you-on-a-performance-improvement-plan.md", "text": "https://wpnews.pro/news/show-hn-pip-your-git-history-puts-you-on-a-performance-improvement-plan.txt", "jsonld": "https://wpnews.pro/news/show-hn-pip-your-git-history-puts-you-on-a-performance-improvement-plan.jsonld"}}