The Pentagon says Anthropic is still a blacklisted supply chain risk. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick says the company is back in the government's good graces. Both cabinet-level officials are talking about the same week.
Pentagon says the label stands. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick says the company is "back on the right side." Those two sentences describe the same week, the same administration, and the same company, and they do not agree.
On September 2, Lutnick told Axios that Anthropic has earned its way back into the government's good graces. "We trust Anthropic," he said. "They've done what we asked. They're back on the right side." Days earlier, Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering Emil Michael said the opposite is still true where it counts. Anthropic remains a designated "supply chain risk" at the Department of Defense and for the broader defense industrial base, he said, a label the Pentagon has not budged on despite a federal judge's ruling against it.
That ruling landed on August 27. U.S. District Judge Rita Lin of the Northern District of California issued a roughly 59-page decision finding that the Pentagon's blacklisting of Anthropic violated the company's First Amendment and Fifth Amendment rights, calling the government's national-security justification "arbitrary and capricious." Back in March, at an earlier hearing in the same case, Lin had already signaled where she was headed, saying the designation "looks like an attempt to cripple Anthropic." Her August order directs the government to rescind the directives it issued against the company. Michael's position is that the order doesn't reach the specific mechanism keeping the designation alive.
So which is it? Reconciled, or still blacklisted? Both, apparently, depending on which department you ask.
Anthropic Gets Its Most Powerful AI Models Back After an 18-Day Fight With Washington
The Department of Commerce has lifted an export control order that forced Anthropic to pull Claude Fable 5 and Mythos 5 offline worldwide after Amazon researchers found a jailbreak in the models. The 18-day standoff ends just as Anthropic works through a confidential IPO filing valuing the company near $965 billion. - anthropic claude fable 5 restrictions - AI model export controls lifted
The dispute traces back to February 27, when President Trump directed federal agencies to stop using Anthropic's products and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth designated the company a supply chain risk, a label typically reserved for foreign adversarial firms like Huawei. According to NPR and Axios, it was the first time a U.S. company had received it. The trigger wasn't espionage or chip smuggling. It was contract language. Anthropic had refused to strip two restrictions from its Pentagon deal: no use of Claude for fully autonomous lethal weapons without a human in the loop, and no use for mass domestic surveillance of Americans. The Pentagon wanted unrestricted access. Anthropic said no.
Judge Lin's ruling was a clear win for Anthropic on paper. In practice, the Pentagon is treating it as a legal technicality rather than a directive to stand down. Michael maintains the court's order doesn't touch the authority he says keeps the designation active, and Anthropic has reportedly gone to the appeals court seeking a stay while the fight continues. Meanwhile, Anthropic co-founder Tom Brown has taken a more visible role courting the administration, including a headline appearance at the G20 Innovation Ministerial the same week Lutnick made his comments. The charm offensive is working on Commerce. It is not working on Defense.
Sen. Ted Cruz has publicly poked at the inconsistency without fully taking Anthropic's side. Asked about the ban on CNBC's Squawk Box, the Texas Republican, who chairs the Senate Commerce Committee, said he had "not seen a basis laid out" for excluding the company, and called Claude "one of the many AI tools that can be very helpful." But he also called Hegseth's underlying instinct "reasonable on the face of it," agreeing that the military shouldn't let a private company set its strategy. Cruz isn't defending Anthropic's safety carve-outs. He's questioning whether banning the company was ever a proportionate response to them.
What it costs Anthropic #
The practical fallout is a set of contracts Anthropic isn't getting. After the February blacklisting, the Pentagon expanded its roster for classified agentic AI work to eight companies that do not include Anthropic: OpenAI, Google, Nvidia, Reflection AI, Microsoft, Amazon Web Services, SpaceX, and Palantir integration partners, according to reporting from DefenseScoop and NBC News. OpenAI, Google, and xAI had each been in line for roughly $200 million in Pentagon work and, per NPR, agreed to let their tools be used for any lawful purpose, no carve-outs attached. Anthropic didn't.
That's the real stakes behind the Lutnick-Michael split. It isn't just a messaging problem inside the administration. It's a test of whether an AI lab can hold a safety line on autonomous weapons and mass surveillance and still get federal work, or whether refusing those two things is enough to get frozen out no matter what a court says. Right now, the answer depends on which office in Washington you're standing in.
Also read: Nvidia's Free PAIR Tool Turns Your Idle Home PCs Into a Private AI Cluster • ChatGPT, Claude and Grok Crashed Together in a Rare Triple Outage • Saudi Arabia Built Its National AI Model on Top of China's MiniMax
Founder discussion #
Open in the community → Almost there. Sign in and your reply posts straight away.
Anthropic Open-Sources Claude Commerce Agents Blueprint Ahead of Black Friday Anthropic has open-sourced Claude Commerce Agents, a free GitHub blueprint for building AI shopping and merchant agents, claiming pilot retailers saw carts grow up to 35% and purchases complete 60% more often. The release lands three months before Black Friday, just as OpenAI has pulled back from running checkout directly inside ChatGPT after weak... - how to build AI shopping agents with Claude - commerce agent blueprint for increasing customer cart conversions