{"slug": "not-everything-needs-to-be-accelerated-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-bans-in", "title": "“Not Everything Needs to Be Accelerated”: SSCD Master Jenny Trinitapoli on Technology Bans in the Core", "summary": "The University of Chicago's Social Sciences Collegiate Division issued a memo in August declaring social sciences Core sequences are \"best understood as a pedagogical setting without AI,\" with device-free classrooms as the default, SSCD Master Jenny Trinitapoli told the Chicago Maroon. The humanities Core sequences adopted similar guidelines shortly afterward, even as the University began providing free Claude enterprise access to students, faculty and staff without a comprehensive AI strategy for academic settings. Trinitapoli said the guidelines are \"a statement of continuity\" preserving the 18-to-19-student seminar format, and that Core chairs have discussed LLMs since 2022.", "body_md": "This past August, the Social Sciences Collegiate Division (SSCD) [issued](https://chicagomaroon.com/53262/news/sosc-core-to-institute-ai-ban-technology-free-classrooms-this-fall/) a memo saying that, going forward, social sciences (sosc) Core sequences are “best understood as a pedagogical setting without AI,” and that classrooms would operate device-free as a default. The humanities Core sequences [adopted](https://chicagomaroon.com/53724/news/alivisatos-suggests-new-computational-thinking-core-requirement-coming-next-year/) a similar set of guidelines shortly afterward.\n\nThe memo, written by SSCD Master Jenny Trinitapoli in consultation with sequence chairs and instructors, outlined a series of pedagogical arguments for banning AI in the College’s introductory reading and writing curriculum. It framed a prohibition on artificial intelligence as a natural extension of the University’s intention of teaching “students to read, write, and think beyond the bounds of conventional views or leading ideologies.”\n\nAt the same time as some Core courses are prohibiting AI and limiting device usage, the University began [providing](https://chicagomaroon.com/52867/news/university-announces-claude-enterprise-access-for-students-faculty-staff/) free access to the Claude suite of large language models (LLMs), and the University has not outlined a comprehensive strategy for how AI should or should not be used in academic settings.\n\nThe *Maroon* spoke to Trinitapoli—a professor of sociology and an instructor in the Global Studies sosc sequence—to learn more about the discussions leading up to the memo’s release, how implementation is going, and what it means to teach academic reading and writing in the age of AI.\n\n*Note: This interview has been edited for clarity and brevity. You can* [*hear*](https://chicagomaroon.com/54797/podcast/new-sosc-ai-guidelines-with-jenny-trinitapoli/) *more of the* Maroon*’s reporting on tech-related changes to the Core, including an audio version of this interview, on the Maroon Weekly podcast*.\n\n**Could you explain what these guidelines for Social Science Core sequences are and what they’re intended to do?**\n\nThe approach that we settled on as [sosc Core sequence] chairs is actually really a statement—the statement of guidelines is really a statement of continuity, and it’s also a statement of our norms and the culture of learning in a seminar environment.\n\nAs you know, in sosc Core, the classes are 18 or 19 students. It’s really important to us that the opportunity to learn in the seminar environment, which is so different from in lectures in the lecture hall and in other types of learning, is preserved during a time of a lot of change, and having a distraction-free environment is something that many professors in the Core have been insisting on and maintaining over a long period of time.… I don’t want to say we lost track of our norms, but I think norms were shifting when we came back from online learning [during the COVID-19 pandemic] to being in person again.\n\nThe Core chairs meet to talk about our curriculum, to talk about students, to talk about what’s going well in our classes, to talk about learning, and to talk about logistics on at least a quarterly basis. The seminar [format] and distractions [have] been a big topic of conversation, with most faculty teaching in device-free format already.\n\nNow, the introduction of LLMs is another thing that has really changed. I think all the Core chairs have been discussing this since 2022, and that’s really when the first—we call them superficially competent—LLMs came out, and some of us had the experience of seeing student work that seemed generated by [AI], [student work] that was like a word salad.\n\n[So, in the memo] we’re talking about, you know, how do we talk to students about this? What’s the proper approach? And as these tools have developed more, what is their role [in classrooms]? It’s an important question—what is [AI’s] role in learning for sosc Core? And basically coming up with an articulation of the fact that LLMs do not support the goals of reading, and thinking, and discussing ideas with classmates over a sustained period of time—something that sosc Core uniquely facilitates. We have so many amazing classes at our institution, but the fact that this is the only year-long sequence that students [are required to] participate in, and that the conversation is sustained over the full year, seems really unique and something that was at the center of our attention.\n\nThis guidance document… was put together by faculty who have leadership positions in the sosc Core and are experienced teachers and have been thinking about studying these issues for a long time, and have been in the classroom every year, if not every quarter, over a really long period of time. And senior faculty don’t necessarily need guidance.… But we also have a lot of junior colleagues and junior faculty joining our institution, and [we wanted to have] a clear articulation to people who come in new in a variety of roles and are going to be contributing to sosc: What’s distinct about teaching in sosc Core compared to teaching an undergraduate class in your department?\n\nWell, what’s different is that this is a common syllabus. What’s different is that your students hang together the entire year, even if their professor changes. What’s different is that these syllabi are, you know, they’re constructed through a process, an intellectual process.… So, in that sense, [junior faculty were] a really important audience for guidance. The Core chairs felt it was important to have a document like this that we can share with instructors and help socialize them to the institution.\n\nStudents, of course, are not the recipients of the document as we wrote it, but we have students firmly in mind when we make every decision, and your care and your investment in your own education and the expectations that you should have for the Core curriculum [are] really, really important.\n\nWe are asking all students to take a year-long sequence. It’s three courses, and we think that students should have clarity on both the learning goals for the courses and the conditions that professors are committed to maintaining, so that those learning goals can be accomplished. Eliminating distractions is one of those, and another one is giving students clarity about the use of LLMs in their work. \n\n**As these guidelines were being developed, was it pretty unanimous from the professors’ side—the people that were involved in creating them? Was anybody not supportive of them, or was pretty much everybody saying yes, let’s do this?**\n\n We had strong consensus at the beginning of the year. Everyone thought that this was an important time for us to get clarity, and working on this over the summer felt important to us as well, so that we weren’t giving guidance, you know, the week before classes began. We tried to get ourselves together in July, but this really emerged from more than a years-long conversation preceding it about what’s happening in our classes.\n\nI think both the leadership change [and] the fact that the Claude licenses were being rolled out for faculty and for students this summer made this summer a good time to get everything together in writing. [*Trinitapoli became SSCD master this summer, succeeding psychology professor Howard Nusbaum.*] I used the phrase “strong consensus” in the document and that’s really true. Everyone who is teaching right now, I think, feels this need to have guidance and collaboration on issues of pedagogy.\n\n**Were you guys pleased with the traction that [the guidelines] picked up in the national news? You said you were a little surprised.**\n\nI was really surprised…. The fact that people all over the world were interested in this really surprised me, and I think it says a few things. The first is how much people look to the University of Chicago for leadership on issues related to taking intellectual life seriously. The reputation that we have for that is strong and far-reaching. It’s truly global.\n\n**Could you describe what makes the University of Chicago’s educational culture unique? I know there’s a lot of students nowadays who feel like—and maybe having devices in classrooms is part of this—like, we’re not the way that we used to be. Do you think these guidelines are in some way going to bring us back?**\n\nUnderstanding what happens in the Core, and the distinctiveness of the Core, is something you really need to [participate in to understand]—I needed to participate in it for a while before I really understood what it was. I understood what it was from the websites and from the curricular side of things. I understood that I would be teaching one of my courses every year in this thing called [the] Core. But it takes a while to really understand the importance of this in our curriculum and how it’s shared by students over time.\n\nTalking to alumni is one place where this comes up a lot. People who have been out [of the College] for 10 years or far longer remember what they took in sosc and what they were reading, and are excited to talk about it when they come back to campus.… These guidelines, in thinking about a device-free classroom and thinking about strong norms against the use of AI for reading and for writing about the social world, [are] not a preservationist fantasy, right? [We’re not thinking,] “Let’s get back to the good old days when students read more and everything was better.” That’s not how I think about the world at all.\n\nBut I also, you know, study the life course. I’ve been teaching here for a long time. I understand what changed during the COVID years and how that affected the educational experience on our campus, and also for high school students. I think there are many students who have probably not in their lives been asked to put their phones away and focus on a single text for 80 minutes at a time in conversation, and being a place where the conditions are such and… support that activity seems very essential.\n\n**As far as implementing the new guidelines, has that gone the way that you thought it would? Have you guys run into any difficulties? Any hiccups?**\n\n The response has been overwhelmingly positive. I think that faculty are really clear on the fact that the device-free environment is supporting discussion, and that feels really important. The students that I’m talking to have also—I think there’s a sense in the world that “oh the grownups are taking away the kids’ toys, we’re taking away your phones,” and that’s not at all been my experience from conversations with students. I think that most students really appreciate clarity on a device-free environment more than anything else, and that getting clarity too on policies such as, “Is Claude acceptable for this assignment, or is it not acceptable?” is something that feels really important for students.\n\nAs far as hiccups are concerned, printing’s been an issue, right? … It’s not simply a response to analog sosc guidance, but many instructors are going back to course packs and printing more for their students, supplementary materials, syllabi, etc. And so there has been, you know, in a very short period of time, a massive increase in printing volume on campus, and that’s something that some amazing colleagues are working on, and we’ll keep you posted.\n\n**Do you feel like you’re getting support from the University as a whole as far as your infrastructure needs go?**\n\nAbsolutely. I mean, one of the things that I really, really like about this place is just how devoted so many people are…. The culture of this place is all about rolling up your sleeves and solving problems and working together to make sure that these changes in the curriculum can be supported, and that our teaching is excellent, and that both students and faculty have what they need to do well in their Core courses—in all of their courses, but specifically, my mind’s on the Core.\n\n**One thing that I think is interesting is that you guys are doing this at the same time that the University is providing Claude subscriptions to everyone. Is that something that you were surprised by or did the University come to you guys? Were you involved in that decision? Do you feel we’re cohesively pursuing intellectual education on all sides of the University?** \n\nWell, I was definitely not a part of the group that made the decision about Claude, but faculty were informed that this was happening well in advance and given time to think about it and plan. I think that time to think and work in smaller groups is really, really important.\n\nYou know, we have been relying very heavily on very thoughtful and important reports that colleagues wrote in the last couple of years about AI and education. There was an AI and education working group. They [produced](https://uchicago.app.box.com/s/juyoc1io9tkln146qwn6ivaln58da890?) a report that gave us two really great frameworks for thinking about what’s happening in education right now. One is that our approach to AI should be skeptical, ethical, and ambitious, and the second was a framework of [thinking](https://chicagomaroon.com/53821/news/university-writing-advisory-group-recommends-device-free-classes-and-campus-spaces/) about education here with, without, and about AI.\n\nAnd when asked to situate ourselves in that triangle—with, without, about—how sosc Core fits is clarified pretty quickly. Learning without AI in one context does not preclude students from learning with it in any other. And I think that developing our ability to read hard texts on our own is something that is where we need to continue to cultivate here, even as so many other things in the world move in the direction of expediency, summaries, and just acceleration. Not everything needs to be accelerated, and the reading of difficult texts is one of those things that is worth doing slowly.\n\n**I know many classes already had no-AI policies, but now that’s implemented in this guidance. And I know some professors are moving to in-class essays. What do you think about the difficult problem of determining whether or not and to what extent students use AI in their essays? Do you think you’re getting better at determining if students are using AI? Anything that you want to speak to.**\n\nI really appreciate the fact that this question is coming up toward the end of our conversation, because talking about learning is the most important thing, and then talking about cheating is a different thing. And so if students are misusing AI to write an essay for class, and they understand the policies of the class, that is cheating. That is bad. We want to discourage this, and everybody knows this, right?\n\nCheating is also not new. There have been many different kinds of cheating for a very, very long time, including people hiring others to write their papers for them, right? … I think the kinds of work that students are asked to produce in sosc Core varies. Some students are writing take-home essays. Others are only doing in-course essay writing and exams. Professors also vary in terms of the tools that they’re using in order to detect and enforce no-AI-for-writing policies in their class.\n\nThe thing that I have heard over multiple years, and especially leading up to writing our guidance document for sosc Core from instructors here and also at other institutions, is I don’t want to be an AI cop. [Being an] AI cop is not my job. I want to teach my students. I want to read their work, and I think that’s [an] important thing to keep in mind about how professors are thinking about this. It’s really discouraging to spend time reading through a set of essays that feel AI-generated. Nobody wants that.\n\n**As you mentioned, the pace of life is increasing in every aspect. We’re seeing this drive toward efficiency, productivity, maybe even in some ways in the humanities, judging by the extreme amounts of reading that students seem to have felt like they had to use AI to complete. As far as these guidelines go, do you think that humanity has turned a corner, so to speak, where AI is now going to forever become an increasing part of our lives? Or do these guidelines represent that as humans we can still make these choices to preserve the humanity of our life, and it’s something that people are going to be excited about?**\n\nWell, I think that AI is here to stay, and it’s something that we’ll be grappling with in our workplaces and in our personal lives and in our homes for a long period of time. But at the same time nothing is inevitable, and we are making decisions ourselves and in small groups about the environments that we’re maintaining in our homes, in various social situations, in classrooms… We’re going to have these minds that we cultivate for the rest of our lives, right?\n\nAnd in that sense, I am often defaulting to sports metaphors.… If you want to become a better runner, you can’t outsource that running to anything else, right? You can’t really accelerate that process of becoming stronger by lifting your weights faster, right? It’s not how it’s done. Actually, lifting weights slowly is a really effective way to build strength. So having discernment about the things that are worth accelerating and things that need to be done slowly and independently, or in small groups, unassisted by machines, is something that feels very, very important.", "url": "https://wpnews.pro/news/not-everything-needs-to-be-accelerated-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-bans-in", "canonical_source": "https://chicagomaroon.com/54807/news/uncommon-interview-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-technology-bans-in-the-core/", "published_at": "2026-11-17 01:06:35+00:00", "updated_at": "2026-11-17 20:10:42.671066+00:00", "lang": "en", "topics": ["ai-policy", "artificial-intelligence", "large-language-models"], "entities": ["University of Chicago", "Social Sciences Collegiate Division", "Jenny Trinitapoli", "Chicago Maroon", "Claude", "Core curriculum"], "also_reported_by": [], "takeaway": null, "recommendation": null, "alternates": {"html": "https://wpnews.pro/news/not-everything-needs-to-be-accelerated-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-bans-in", "markdown": "https://wpnews.pro/news/not-everything-needs-to-be-accelerated-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-bans-in.md", "text": "https://wpnews.pro/news/not-everything-needs-to-be-accelerated-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-bans-in.txt", "jsonld": "https://wpnews.pro/news/not-everything-needs-to-be-accelerated-sscd-master-jenny-trinitapoli-on-bans-in.jsonld"}}