Everything Made by an AI Is in the Public Domain US District Judge Beryl A. Howell of the DC Circuit Court upheld a US Copyright Office ruling that works created by AI are not eligible for copyright protection, a decision the author frames as a major labor win for creative workers. Under US law and international treaties including the Berne Convention and TRIPS, copyright requires creativity, fixation in a tangible medium, and human authorship, so algorithm-generated images, audio, text, and video cannot be copyrighted. The author argues this removes employers' incentive to replace workers with AI, since AI output would enter the public domain. The US Copyright Office offers creative workers a powerful labor protective. Last week, a US federal judge handed America’s creative workers a huge labor win: Judge Beryl A Howell of the DC Circuit Court upheld a US Copyright Office ruling that works created by “AIs” are not eligible for copyright protection https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/ai-generated-art-lacks-copyright-protection-d-c-court-rules . This is huge. Some background: under US law https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17 — and under a mountain of international treaties, from the Berne Convention https://www.wipo.int/treaties/en/ip/berne/ to the TRIPS https://www.wto.org/english/tratop e/trips e/intel2 e.htm —copyright is automatically granted to creative works of human authorship “at the moment of fixation in some tangible medium.” That is: as soon as a human being makes something creative , and records it in some medium a hard-drive, magnetic tape, paper, film, canvas, etc , that creative thing is immediately copyrighted the duration of that copyright varies, both by territory and by whether the creator was working on their own or for a corporation . That means that for a work to be eligible for copyright in the USA, it must satisfy three criteria: 1. It must be creative . Copyright does not apply to non-creative works say, a phone book listing everyone in a town in alphabetical order , even if the work required a lot of labor . Copyright does not protect effort , it protects creativity. You can spend your whole life making a phone book and get no copyright, but the haiku you toss off in ten seconds while drunk gets copyright’s full protection. 2. It must be tangible . Copyright only applies to creative works that are “fixed in a tangible medium.” A dance isn’t copyrightable, but a video of someone dancing is, as is a written description of the dance in choreographers’ notation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dance notation . A singer can’t copyright the act of singing, but they can copyright the recording of the song. 3. It must be of human authorship . Only humans are eligible for copyright . A beehive’s combs may be beautiful https://mymodernmet.com/transparent-beehive-ivry-b/ , but they can’t be copyrighted. An elephant’s paintings may be creative https://www.treehugger.com/can-elephants-really-paint-4864229 , but they can’t be copyrighted. A monkey’s selfie may be iconic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monkey selfie copyright dispute , but it can’t be copyrighted. The works an algorithm generates —be they still images, audio recordings, text, or videos — cannot be copyrighted . For creative workers, this is huge. Our bosses, like all bosses, relish the thought of firing us all and making us homeless https://uproxx.com/movies/hollywood-studios-want-writers-to-go-broke-homeless-wga-strike/ . You will never love anything as much as your boss hates paying you. That’s why the most rampant form of theft in America is wage theft https://www.epi.org/publication/employers-steal-billions-from-workers-paychecks-each-year/ . Just the thought of firing workers and replacing them with chatbots is enough to invoke dangerous, persistent priapism in the boardrooms of corporate America. They really want to fire us and replace us with plausible sentence generators https://locusmag.com/2023/09/commentary-by-cory-doctorow-plausible-sentence-generators/ and the world’s most derivative imagery https://defector.com/ai-art-sucks-ass-and-you-should-say-its-bad . The fact that these apps are objectively terrible at doing our jobs https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/artificial-intelligence-microsoft-travel-ottawa-food-bank-1.6940356 doesn’t enter into their calculations. Bosses believe they have a captive audience, thanks to massive market concentration https://www.openmarketsinstitute.org/learn/monopoly-by-the-numbers , and that we will continue to pay for substandard work delivered in worse ways because they’re the only game in town. The most perfect form of American business is the airport snack-bar. The federal government has turned airport security into a multi-hour, multi-stage ordeal, such that every flier needs to arrive at the airport with hours to spare, and then trap themselves on the “safe” side of the TSA checkpoint. Any business on that side of the checkpoint has a license to print money: you can charge $12 for a 300ml bottle of water, or $18 for a saranwrapped cheese sandwich and people will pay for it. What choice do they have? Add the TSA to the airport snack bar and you have the platonic ideal of a public-private partnership, a combination of state intervention and feverish capitalism that no flier can escape. Enshittification https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/ hey-guys requires a captive audience. For executives running entertainment businesses, the temptation to lower quality and raise prices is irresistible. If you’re one of the five publishers, or four studios, or three labels, or two mobile app stores, or the single, solitary company that controls all the ebooks and audiobooks, you can sell garbage at inflated prices https://www.vice.com/en/article/v7b774/ai-generated-books-of-nonsense-are-all-over-amazons-bestseller-lists and people will buy it…for a while. Our bosses will fire our asses and replace us with software, even if the software sucks at doing our jobs https://garymarcus.substack.com/p/what-if-generative-ai-turned-out . They do this all the time . Remember when a human being who worked at the business you were calling answered the phone? First, they replaced those workers with contractors on the other side of the world who weren’t allowed to solve your problem, only read from a script. Then they fired those humans and replaced them with “interactive voice response systems” that don’t even pretend to solve our problems, only make us repeat ourselves over and over again: “Seventeen. No. Seventeen. No. Seven. Teen. No . One. Seven. Operator. Representative. Operator. Operator. Operator. Fuuuuuuuuck