{"slug": "europes-top-human-rights-court-bans-a-lawyer-for-two-years-over-ai-invented", "title": "Europe’s top human rights court bans a lawyer for two years over AI-invented cases", "summary": "The European Court of Human Rights barred a Romanian lawyer from representing applicants before it for two years after her written submissions cited nonexistent judgments, quoted paragraphs never written, and relied on real case law that contradicted her arguments; she admitted using AI tools to draft the filings. The Chamber found \"a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes\" and said for some references \"no checks whatsoever had been carried out,\" with many errors detectable by a cursory check of the court's HUDOC database. The exclusion was approved by the court's President on November 13 under Rule 44D of the Rules of Court, which permits barring a lawyer only in \"exceptional circumstances\"; the court did not name the lawyer, the applicants or the case, and the applicants' case can continue through the second representative.", "body_md": "The main courtroom of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France (file photo). Image: [Adrian Grycuk](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Courtroom_European_Court_of_Human_Rights_01.JPG) / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 PL, cropped\n\nThe European Court of Human Rights has [barred a Romanian lawyer](https://www.echr.coe.int/w/romanian-lawyer-barred-for-two-years-from-representing-applicants-before-the-court-over-unverified-ai-generated-citations) from representing anyone before it for two years, after her written submissions cited cases that do not exist, quoted paragraphs that were never written and leaned on real judgments that said the opposite. She admitted using AI tools to draft them.\n\n## What the lawyer filed\n\nThe lawyer was one of two representatives acting for applicants in a case before one of the Strasbourg court’s Chambers. Her written observations, the court says, were riddled with errors about its own case law.\n\nAccording to the court’s [press release](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?library=ECHR&id=003-8699897-12417749&filename=Romanian%20lawyer%20barred%20from%20representing%20applicants%20before%20the%20Court%20over%20unverified%20AI-generated%20case-law%20citations.pdf), published on November 18, they included:\n\n- **Invented cases:** citations to judgments that do not exist, which the court calls “hallucinated”.\n- **Fictitious paragraphs:** passages attributed to genuine judgments and decisions that contain no such text.\n- **Wrong authorities:** real case law that was irrelevant to the point being made, or that “plainly contradicted” the argument it was meant to support.\n\nThe lawyer acknowledged that she had used “Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools” to draft the observations. The court does not say which tools. She described the mistakes as “inaccuracies” and “citation errors”.\n\nThe Chamber did not accept that. It found “a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors rather than isolated citation mistakes” and concluded that her conduct “fell short of the professional and ethical duties imposed by the Court”.\n\n## “No checks whatsoever”\n\nUnder Romania’s Legal Profession Act and the court’s own case law, the Chamber said, lawyers must act as reasonably competent professionals and show “a high level of professional prudence” in Strasbourg. That meant checking every case reference and argument the AI produced against authoritative sources, such as the court’s free HUDOC database, before filing.\n\nThe lawyer admitted she had not checked all the case law she cited. The Chamber called that admission “an understatement”: for some references, it found, “no checks whatsoever had been carried out”. Many of the errors were repeated and “would have been easily detectable by a cursory check of HUDOC”.\n\nThe judges also found that the filing had harmed the administration of justice. The court had to spend “considerable time” verifying the observations, open disciplinary proceedings and correspond at length with others involved, work it described as “incompatible with the Court’s real functions under the Convention”.\n\n## A two-year ban\n\nThe Chamber sent a reasoned proposal to the court’s President, who approved it on November 13. The exclusion was made under Rule 44D of the Rules of Court, which allows a lawyer to be barred from representing or assisting any party only in “exceptional circumstances”. The Chamber found that threshold was met.\n\nBefore deciding, it invited comments from the lawyer, the Romanian government and the Romanian National Bar Association. The Iași Bar Association was also asked but did not respond. The ban covers only one of the two representatives, so the applicants’ case can continue, and the lawyer can later apply to have her right of representation restored.\n\nThe court has not named the lawyer, the applicants or the case.\n\n## Courts are losing patience\n\nJudges in many countries have fined or reprimanded lawyers over AI-invented citations, but a ban from appearing before an international court is a step up. The problem has reached the bench too: in October a US appeals court [took a case away from federal judge Henry Wingate](https://madrobot.blog/2026/10/23/fifth-circuit-removes-judge-henry-wingate-ai-hallucinated-order-mississippi-dei-law/) after AI errors, including a fake case, turned up in his orders.\n\nIn the UK, a judge set out rules for anyone using AI in court after a litigant filed a [300-page ChatGPT-written skeleton argument](https://madrobot.blog/2026/09/24/chatgpt-skeleton-argument-longer-than-pride-and-prejudice-tribunal/). AI companies are now selling the fix: Anthropic added a [cite check to Claude for Legal](https://madrobot.blog/2026/10/28/claude-for-legal-cite-check-artifacts/) in October that flags misquoted or unsupported sources.\n\n## Why it matters\n\nEurope’s top human rights court hears cases from 46 countries, and losing the right to appear there for two years is a serious blow to a lawyer’s practice. The message from Strasbourg is plain: using AI is not the offence, filing what it writes without checking it is.\n\n*Sources: [European Court of Human Rights](https://www.echr.coe.int/w/romanian-lawyer-barred-for-two-years-from-representing-applicants-before-the-court-over-unverified-ai-generated-citations), [ECHR press release ECHR 290 (2026)](https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/app/conversion/pdf/?library=ECHR&id=003-8699897-12417749&filename=Romanian%20lawyer%20barred%20from%20representing%20applicants%20before%20the%20Court%20over%20unverified%20AI-generated%20case-law%20citations.pdf).*", "url": "https://wpnews.pro/news/europes-top-human-rights-court-bans-a-lawyer-for-two-years-over-ai-invented", "canonical_source": "https://madrobot.blog/2026/11/20/echr-bans-lawyer-ai-hallucinated-citations/", "published_at": "2026-11-20 19:25:00+00:00", "updated_at": "2026-11-20 19:42:51.381807+00:00", "lang": "en", "topics": ["ai-policy", "ai-ethics", "artificial-intelligence"], "entities": ["European Court of Human Rights", "Romanian National Bar Association", "Iași Bar Association", "HUDOC", "Romania"], "also_reported_by": [], "takeaway": null, "recommendation": null, "alternates": {"html": "https://wpnews.pro/news/europes-top-human-rights-court-bans-a-lawyer-for-two-years-over-ai-invented", "markdown": "https://wpnews.pro/news/europes-top-human-rights-court-bans-a-lawyer-for-two-years-over-ai-invented.md", "text": "https://wpnews.pro/news/europes-top-human-rights-court-bans-a-lawyer-for-two-years-over-ai-invented.txt", "jsonld": "https://wpnews.pro/news/europes-top-human-rights-court-bans-a-lawyer-for-two-years-over-ai-invented.jsonld"}}