# Back in lower court, Amazon wants to continue suit against AI assistant

> Source: <https://courthousenews.com/back-in-lower-court-amazon-wants-to-continue-suit-against-ai-assistant/>
> Published: 2026-11-20 23:47:42+00:00

SAN FRANCISCO (CN) — “I really don’t know what to do with this case,” Senior U.S. District Judge Maxine Chesney said Friday as a legal fight between Amazon and Perplexity AI returned to her court.

By the end of the three-hour hearing, the Bill Clinton appointee had granted Perplexity’s request for a stay in discovery, saying it would keep costs down and give her time to consider a dismissal motion. Neither Amazon nor Perplexity immediately responded to requests for comment.

Perplexity is the developer of Comet, an AI web browser capable of shopping on Amazon, including by comparing prices and reviews.

Amazon argues the tool [violates laws](https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/amazon-vs-perplexity-complaint.pdf) like the U.S. Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. Chesney [previously found](https://www.courthousenews.com/amazon-wins-block-against-ai-powered-shopping-assistant/) that Amazon would likely succeed on those arguments — then a Ninth Circuit panel [rejected her findings](https://www.courthousenews.com/ninth-circuit-lifts-block-on-ai-powered-shopping-assistant/), sending the case back to her court.

In [its ruling](https://www.courthousenews.com/perplexity-ai-asks-ninth-circuit-to-allow-shopping-tool-on-amazon/), the Ninth Circuit found Chesney erred in her analysis of rules prohibiting access “without authorization” or at a level “exceeding authorized access.”

“It is the user who ‘accesses’ Amazon’s computers with the help of the assistant,” U.S. Circuit Judge Milan Smith Jr., a George W. Bush appointee, wrote for the panel. A claim by Amazon under the California Comprehensive Computer Data Access and Fraud Act failed under the same logic.

On Friday, Chesney asked Amazon and Perplexity how she should apply the panel’s ruling.

Hagan Scotten, an attorney with the firm Hueston Hennigan who is representing Amazon, told the judge there were new facts that the appeals court had not considered.

A new version of Comet had been released since the panel’s decision, Scotten said. He also said Perplexity employees had tested versions of Comet on Amazon.

Scotten also argued the panel did not fully understand how Comet works.

The judges, he said, mistakenly believed that Comet only shopped on Amazon when directed by a user to do so. In fact, he said, a user might simply ask Comet to buy an item, then the tool would go to Amazon without being “invited in.”

“Perplexity and Perplexity alone is sending the agent to Amazon, which answers the panel’s question about who is in control here,” Scotten said, describing Perplexity as a “rogue actor” that was violating Amazon restrictions on AI tools.

“You are very persuasive,” Chesney told Scotten. Nonetheless, she said she was trying to be “very careful [so] you don’t take me down another path that results in a reversal.”

Representing Perplexity with the firm Quinn Emanuel, attorney Daniel Posner pushed back on Scotten’s claims, including the argument that facts had changed since the Ninth Circuit ruling.

Comet cannot access Amazon itself, he said. Instead, a user must give the AI assistant access to their Amazon account.

“The user always directs the agent to do something," he said. “That is the underpinning of the Ninth Circuit ruling.”

Posner argued Amazon was “scraping the barrel” in an effort to save its case. He cited Amazon’s claims that Perplexity employees were accessing Amazon.

“As I understand, the allegation is that some unspecified number of Perplexity employees used their own Amazon accounts to access Amazon," he said. “If that type of conduct is criminalized, that would hit the panel opinion head-on.”

#### Subscribe to our free newsletters

Our weekly newsletter *Closing Arguments* offers the latest about ongoing
trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world,
while the monthly *Under the Lights* dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood,
sports, Big Tech and the arts.
