German intelligence reform: Add protest by automotive lobby against use of car telemetry data by intelligence, add background on the same minister deliberatly introducing an unconstitutional law in order to enact it until overturned by a court
| ← Older revision | Revision as of 09:32, 15 August 2026 | || | Line 612: | Line 612: | || |Significantly expands the powers of German intelligence agencies. | |Significantly expands the powers of German intelligence agencies. | || Suggested by Minister of Interior Alexander Dobrindt of Christian conservative party CSU. | Suggested by Minister of Interior Alexander Dobrindt of Christian conservative party CSU. | || The proposed changes includes the permission to hack systems, to use, train and buy AI, including foreign solutions like those from Peter Thiel's [[Palantir]]. Public and private cameras (presumably including cars, vacuum robots, laptop, TV, phone cameras and more) may be hacked and their feeds analyzed in real-time, including AI face and biometric recognition. It also allows for large-scale internet surveillance and reduces transparency and control. | The proposed changes includes the permission to hack systems, to use, train and buy AI, including foreign solutions like those from Peter Thiel's [[Palantir]]. Public and private cameras (presumably including cars, vacuum robots, laptop, TV, phone cameras and more) may be hacked and their feeds analyzed in real-time, including AI face and biometric recognition. It also allows for large-scale internet surveillance and reduces transparency and control. | || Moreover, the Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) would have to disclose zero-day vulnerabilites to intelligence agencies. | Moreover, the Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) would have to disclose zero-day vulnerabilites to intelligence agencies. | || The division of intelligence gathering and the power of taking action, which the bill seeks to abolish, was introduced in Germany after the end of WW2 based on the bad experiences with secret state police (Gestapo) under the Nazi regime. | ||| The extent to which this law would grant real-time access to car telemetry data has sparked protest from the German car lobby.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Briegleb |first=Volker |date=2026-08-14 |title=Access to telemetry data: Automotive industry criticizes intelligence reform |url=https://www.heise.de/en/news/Access-to-telemetry-data-Automotive-industry-criticizes-intelligence-reform-11414994.html |access-date=2026-08-15 |website=Heise Online}}</ref> | ||| The division of intelligence gathering and the power of taking action, which the bill seeks to abolish in order to allow for hack backs, was introduced in Germany after the end of WW2 based on the bad experiences with secret state police (Gestapo) under the Nazi regime. | ||| Critics again stipulate that the timing at the beginning of the Berlin summer holidays and during a football world cup is deliberate.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Joswig |first=Gareth |date=2026-07-15 |title=Dobrindts Schnüffeloffensive [Dobrindt’s Snooping Push] |url=https://taz.de/Kritik-an-Geheimdienstreform/!6196285/ |access-date=2026-07-18 |website=TAZ}}</ref> | Critics again stipulate that the timing at the beginning of the Berlin summer holidays and during a football world cup is deliberate.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Joswig |first=Gareth |date=2026-07-15 |title=Dobrindts Schnüffeloffensive [Dobrindt’s Snooping Push] |url=https://taz.de/Kritik-an-Geheimdienstreform/!6196285/ |access-date=2026-07-18 |website=TAZ}}</ref> | || Minister Dobrindt already has a record of demonstrating only limited regard for the constitution. Internal documents obtained under the freedom of information law (IFG), which his government also seeks to abolish, reveal that he had legal advice that his border control laws are unconstitutional, but he still proceeded, knowing that it would take time for a court to overturn the law and in the meantime the illegal border controls could be enforced.<ref>{{Cite web |last=Deleja-Hotko1, Semsrott2 |first=Vera1, Arne2 |date=2026-08-07 |title=Dobrindts Grenzpolitik – Rechtsbruch mit Ansage [Dobrindt's border policies – a deliberate breach of the law] |url=https://fragdenstaat.de/artikel/exklusiv/2026/08/rechtsbruch-mit-ansage/ |access-date=2026-08-15 |website=Frag den Staat}}</ref> | ||| |AI Video Surveillance (private cameras included), Hacking, Internet Mass Surveillance, Hoarding of Zero-Day Vulnerabilities, Reduction of Transparency | |AI Video Surveillance (private cameras included), Hacking, Internet Mass Surveillance, Hoarding of Zero-Day Vulnerabilities, Reduction of Transparency | || |Drafted and presented | |Drafted and presented |