{"slug": "an-italian-court-just-put-a-price-on-i-made-it-with-ai", "title": "An Italian court just put a price on \"I made it with AI\"", "summary": "An Italian court declined to grant an urgent injunction against merchandise based on AI-generated \"Italian Brainrot\" characters, finding that a reconstructed ChatGPT session of six prompts over roughly 14 minutes did not demonstrate authorship under Italy's revised copyright law. The Court of Genoa's November 6, 2026 order, an early application of Law 132/2025's requirement that AI-assisted works reflect the author's own intellectual effort, ordered the claimants to pay about €8,059 in legal fees; the unfair competition claim was deferred to a full trial.", "body_md": "Here’s a question I get asked in planning meetings more often than I’d like: “If we just generate the character with AI, do we own it?” Earlier this month an Italian court gave one very concrete answer, and it involves the weirdest IP of the past two years: Italian Brainrot.\n\n## 🔍 The case\n\nQuick refresher if you’ve avoided the internet: Italian Brainrot is a cast of AI-generated meme creatures with sing-song pseudo-Italian names. Think a shark in sneakers, or a wooden figure holding a bat. It blew up on social video, then spilled into merch. In Japan it even got its own books: KADOKAWA put out an Italian Brainrot encyclopedia in April and a fan book with puffy stickers on August 4 for ¥1,650 ([Iko-yo](https://report.iko-yo.net/articles/30547), [Famitsu](https://www.famitsu.com/article/202608/82676), both Japanese).\n\n**Who sued whom.** On one side: a French rights-management company plus two creators, one based in Indonesia and one in Brazil, who say they made some of the characters. On the other: a children’s collectibles company and its exclusive European licensee for a “Skifidol Italian Brainrot” line. The published order blanks out the company names. Reports describe both respondents as Italian companies ([La Legge per Tutti](https://www.laleggepertutti.it/849833_diritto-dautore-e-ia-per-il-giudice-15-minuti-di-brainrot-non-bastano), Italian).\n\n**What they wanted.** An urgent injunction from the Court of Genoa to stop the products: a trading card game in several series, binders and boxes, 3D figures, sticker albums and an official magazine. They also asked for daily penalties and publication of the order ([PPC Land](https://ppc.land/brainrot-creators-lose-genoa-copyright-bid-over-six-chatgpt-prompts/)).\n\n**What the court said.** No. In an order dated November 6, 2026, the judge found the claimants hadn’t shown a likely copyright at all. The key evidence was a reconstructed ChatGPT session behind the lead character. According to PPC Land’s reading of the order, it shows six prompts (plus a seventh whose result was thrown away) over roughly 14 minutes, and the order sums it up as “only 15 minutes.” The judge said the session could have some circumstantial value. But it was “not an indication of an authorial work as required by the legal framework” ([PPC Land](https://ppc.land/brainrot-creators-lose-genoa-copyright-bid-over-six-chatgpt-prompts/), translated from Italian). An unsigned character list and an unproven description of the creative process didn’t help either.\n\n**The law behind it.** Italy changed Article 1 of its copyright law in 2025 (Law 132/2025). It now says works made with AI tools can be protected, as long as they come out of the author’s own intellectual work ([PPC Land](https://ppc.land/brainrot-creators-lose-genoa-copyright-bid-over-six-chatgpt-prompts/); [La Legge per Tutti](https://www.laleggepertutti.it/849833_diritto-dautore-e-ia-per-il-giudice-15-minuti-di-brainrot-non-bastano)). That’s an early ruling under the new wording. The claimants were ordered to pay about €8,059 of the other side’s legal fees, plus the usual extras.\n\n**What it is NOT.** It’s an interim decision, not a final judgment. The claimants also raised unfair competition, but held it back for a full trial, so the court didn’t rule on it ([PPC Land](https://ppc.land/brainrot-creators-lose-genoa-copyright-bid-over-six-chatgpt-prompts/); [Diritto.it](https://www.diritto.it/opere-generate-con-ai-diritto-autore/), Italian). So “the brainrot creators lost” is true for this round only.\n\n## ⚖️ Why it matters\n\n**For fans and collectors:** short term, nothing changes. The cards and stickers stay on shelves in Italy. Longer term, it’s a reminder that “official” on a meme product can mean very different things. With AI-born characters, it may not be clear who could license them in the first place.\n\n**For the industry, the interesting part is that it’s not just Italy.** Several big systems are landing in the same place:\n\n- **US:** the Supreme Court declined on March 2, 2026, to hear*Thaler v. Perlmutter* , leaving in place the rule that a work needs a human author ([Holland & Knight](https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2026/03/the-final-word-supreme-court-refuses-to-hear-case-on-ai-authorship) ). That case was about an image the AI made fully on its own. The Genoa case is the messier, more common version: a human typed prompts, but was it enough?\n- **Japan:** the Agency for Cultural Affairs’ March 2024 guidance on AI and copyright is not legally binding. It says the parts a human creatively adds or edits on top of AI output are normally protected, and it treats the rest as a case-by-case look at human creative input ([Agency for Cultural Affairs](https://www.bunka.go.jp/seisaku/bunkashingikai/chosakuken/hoseido/r05_07/pdf/94021801_03.pdf) , Japanese;[GameBusiness.jp](https://www.gamebusiness.jp/article/2024/04/19/22981.html) , Japanese).\n\nNone of these say “AI art can never be protected.” What they say is closer to: **show your work.** Genoa basically put that into practice. The court asked for proof of human authorship, looked at what was filed, and decided it wasn’t enough.\n\n## 🧠 Kai’s take\n\nHot take: this ruling matters more for character licensing than for AI art debates.\n\nA character business runs on one boring question: who can say yes? Licensees pay because the licensor can stop everyone else. If your character’s copyright is shaky, that promise gets thin. My guess is that’s the real risk here. Not “AI is bad,” but “AI-made characters are harder to license with confidence.”\n\nFrom the planning side, the practical stuff is pretty unglamorous:\n\n- **Keep the paper trail.** Sketches, turnaround sheets, revision notes, who changed what and when. In Genoa, an unsigned list and an after-the-fact reconstruction didn’t cut it. Dated, signed records seem a lot harder to brush off.\n- **Do the human layer on purpose.** If AI is in the pipeline, the parts people redraw, design and name are the parts most likely to be protected, at least under Japan’s guidance. I’d plan that layer, not leave it to chance.\n- **Don’t lean on copyright alone.** Trademarks on names and logos work differently, and unfair competition claims are still alive in this very case. If I had to bet, future fights over meme characters will lean more on those than on authorship.\n\nAnd a bit of respect for the other side: viral creators often have no studio, no lawyer and no records. Moving fast is how memes happen. The ruling doesn’t say these creators did nothing, only that they couldn’t prove enough in this round.\n\n## 📎 Quick hits\n\n**Character.AI’s sale to Disney hits a wall of states.** On November 18, a coalition of 39 states plus DC objected to Character.AI’s plan to sell a non-exclusive tech license to a Disney affiliate for $20 million in its Chapter 11 case. Texas filed separately, making 40 states plus DC in total. Their arguments are reportedly about price, whether Disney counts as a good-faith buyer, and whether users’ chats, including minors’, could end up inside the licensed tools. An auction is set for December 1 and the sale hearing for December 3–4 ([PPC Land](https://ppc.land/39-states-and-dc-ask-court-to-deny-disneys-20m-character-ai-deal/)). For anyone pitching “talk to your favorite character” toys, user protection is now its own line item, separate from the license.\n\nSo, a question for you. Would knowing a character was mostly AI-generated change whether you’d buy the cards or the plush? And for the makers reading: how much of your design process do you actually write down? Hit reply. I read everything.\n\n*Not legal advice. I make toys, not court filings. This is an interim order from one Italian court, and the full case can still go a different way.*", "url": "https://wpnews.pro/news/an-italian-court-just-put-a-price-on-i-made-it-with-ai", "canonical_source": "https://tokyoticker.substack.com/p/six-prompts-15-minutes-no-copyright", "published_at": "2026-11-20 15:03:51+00:00", "updated_at": "2026-11-20 15:16:38.052603+00:00", "lang": "en", "topics": ["ai-policy", "generative-ai", "artificial-intelligence"], "entities": ["Court of Genoa", "ChatGPT", "OpenAI", "KADOKAWA", "Italian Brainrot", "Italy"], "also_reported_by": [], "takeaway": null, "recommendation": null, "alternates": {"html": "https://wpnews.pro/news/an-italian-court-just-put-a-price-on-i-made-it-with-ai", "markdown": "https://wpnews.pro/news/an-italian-court-just-put-a-price-on-i-made-it-with-ai.md", "text": "https://wpnews.pro/news/an-italian-court-just-put-a-price-on-i-made-it-with-ai.txt", "jsonld": "https://wpnews.pro/news/an-italian-court-just-put-a-price-on-i-made-it-with-ai.jsonld"}}