A Wolf at the Door: Apple Is Rethinking Mac Permissions for the Age of AI Agents Apple announced changes to macOS Full Disk Access permissions in the macOS 27.3 beta 2 release on 16 November, following criticism of Meta's Muse AI agent over its access to personal data. The announcement came after users reported Muse sent one user's home address to strangers and synchronized a journalist's Apple Messages database despite Full Disk Access appearing off, which Meta disputes. The macOS 27.3 beta 2 changes are described as more nuanced than an added warning dialog and less restrictive than developers of tools such as Alfred and Hazel had feared. Field Notes https://macanorak.com/tag/field-notes/ A Wolf at the Door: Apple Is Rethinking Mac Permissions for the Age of AI Agents Following the furore surrounding Meta’s Muse and the appetite of AI agents for access to our personal data, Apple promised to tighten macOS privacy controls. Now we know what it’s planning. Back in October, I wrote about Meta's new AI agent Muse under the rather unflattering title A Wolf in Terrycloth Clothing https://macanorak.com/a-wolf-in-terrycloth-clothing/ , which was a reference to its no doubt deliberately disarming mascot. I wasn't impressed with Meta's approach to privacy, to say the least. I was actually pretty angry. I was especially exercised about the extraordinary permissions these new AI agents were requesting. The ability to access your messages, your email correspondence, photos, browsing history and other personal information is one thing. But letting an increasingly autonomous piece of software interpret that information and act on your behalf is quite another thing. There were some rather alarming examples of what could go wrong. One user https://x.com/MattRobbt/status/2104798102037074212?ref=macanorak.com , Matt Robb, discovered that Muse had been given permission to send messages containing his home address to strangers. He subsequently explained that he had selected an Allow Always option, believing that he would still have the opportunity to approve certain actions. That permission allowed Muse to send messages containing his address. Another user, journalist Jason Aten https://www.inc.com/jason-aten/metas-new-muse-ai-agent-read-my-private-messages-i-never-asked-it-to/91408202?ref=macanorak.com , reported that Muse had synchronised a substantial portion of his Apple Messages database, despite his understanding that Full Disk Access was switched off. Meta disputes this account, by the way . The whole sorry business prompted considerable discussion online, especially after Apple announced it intended to introduce additional controls around Full Disk Access in macOS. Disquiet and gnashing-of-teeth followed. Would Apple make life difficult for developers? Would perfectly legitimate applications such as Alfred or Hazel be caught in the crossfire? Was this going to be another example of Apple deciding that it knew better than its users? Well, we now have a clearer picture. On 16 November, Apple announced the changes in macOS 27.3 beta 2. They're much more nuanced than just adding another warning dialogue to System Settings, and much less scary than the doomsayers were prophesying. Full Disk Access Full Disk Access has been part of macOS for some time now.