50 vs. 60 Hz and Alzheimer's Disease, an AI Exploration

Matt Mankins used AI tools to investigate whether mains electricity frequency (50 Hz vs 60 Hz) correlates with Alzheimer's disease rates, using Japan's internal frequency split as a natural experiment. After pursuing three independent routes, the hypothesis could not be tested with existing data, and the analysis found no evidence of an association.

An exploration into whether mains electricity frequency 50 Hz vs 60 Hz is associated with Alzheimer's disease / dementia burden — using Japan's internal frequency split as a natural experiment. Note I, Matt Mankins Twitter: @mankins , am not a scientist trained in the fields presented here. Do not take this for anything other than what it is: a single-session journey with Anthropic's Claude Code to investigate a whim I had many decades ago--I wondered if the addition of electricity to modern life had anything to do with the rise of some diseases, such as Alzheimer's, a disease that took my grandmother. The conclusions here seem to indicate that no, there's nothing here. What I find interesting was the use of AI to bring me into domains that I would have previously had no ability to interface with. For example in this report we had to both navigate Japanese as well as the domain-specific jargon, and do that while designing an experimental environment that would isolate variables and be actually testable. In my day-to-day doing web or ai platform programming, that's just not something I do. Yet by being curious and asking, I was able to get an answer. Was it the right answer? I think so, but would need to defer to others with more skills to evaluate what was done. This is the AI loop entirely: have a need, collaborate with AI, reach a result, validate with humans. To me the excitement of AI is not that it will do my job for me, but that it will help me understand different parts of the world quicker than I otherwise would be able to. With this new understanding, I can then synthesize, create, and combine to make art, tools, and build knowledge. → Read REPORT.pdf first 14 pp . It is the synthesis of everything below. REPORT.pdf Status: CONCLUDED 2026-07-17 . The hypothesis cannot be tested with existing data. Three independent routes were pursued to exhaustion; each closed for a different reason. This is a stronger result than a null — a null would leave "maybe with more data" open. These findings close specific doors with evidence. | Route | Status | Why | |---|---|---| | International 50/60 by country | Closed | Frequency is a proxy for which empire electrified you. The exposure is the confounder. | | Japan administrative data | Closed | Dementia × municipality does not exist. Dementia × prefecture has no age dimension. | | Japan modelled estimates GBD | Closed | The dementia surface is measurably flat; a placebo separates 5× harder than the outcome. | | Japan population cohorts | Closed | Case-finding intensity is collinear with frequency. | | Ontario 25 Hz experiment | Closed | Exposure was real and large, but 1950s residence was never recorded. | The one finding that runs the other way: the historical Ontario exposure was real and measured — ~30% luminous modulation at 25 Hz vs ~12.5% at 60 Hz. The physics is sound; the measurement is what fails. The number that reframes it all: the luminous-flicker contrast between 50 and 60 Hz mains is 1.2× — a 20% difference in modulation depth of a stimulus below conscious perception. That is the entire signal Japan ever offered. Ambient flicker from mains electricity influences Alzheimer's disease risk. Motivated by: - The observation that clinically recognised Alzheimer's is rare in the historical record before electrification. - The MIT / Tsai lab "GENUS" work showing 40 Hz sensory entrainment reduces amyloid burden in mouse models — establishing that the brain is, in principle, responsive to flicker in this frequency neighbourhood. Japan is the natural test bed: a largely homogeneous population, one health system, one death-registration practice, split down the middle between 50 Hz east and 60 Hz west by an accident of 1890s generator procurement. An initial analysis see docs/original chart UNRELIABLE.png appeared to show a clean separation: 60 Hz 50 Hz Alzheimer's rates, with "mixed" regions highest. That chart does not survive scrutiny — see docs/00 critique of initial analysis.md . In short it used a crude, non-age-standardised mortality measure across groups with radically different age structures, and its pre-1990 segment cannot be produced from the cited sources at all. This repo rebuilds the analysis from the ground up with: Prevalence , not probability of death Alzheimer's mortality largely measures death-certificate coding practice, not disease . Age-standardised rates using 5-year bands — non-negotiable for a disease whose incidence roughly doubles every 5 years after 65. Within-Japan contrast only. The international 50/60 comparison is abandoned: mains frequency at country level is a proxy for 20th-century imperial alignment see docs/01 why international comparison fails.md , which is confounded with every determinant of both dementia risk and dementia measurement .- A pre-registered analysis plan with placebo outcomes and a stated decision rule, written before results are examined METHODS.md . ├── REPORT.md / REPORT.pdf THE SYNTHESIS. Start here. ├── METHODS.md Pre-registration: signed hypothesis, gated pipeline, decision rule ├── LIMITATIONS.md Written before results, so nothing could be dropped later ├── docs/ │ ├── 00 critique of initial analysis.md why the original chart fails 8 findings │ ├── 01 why international comparison fails.md the colonial-history argument │ ├── 02 the ontario 25hz experiment.md the Ontario design verdict revised │ ├── 03 japan data availability.md THE Japan blocker, verified │ ├── 04 ontario ices feasibility.md the exposure was never recorded │ ├── 05 ontario 25hz flicker physics.md primary sources 1906–1930; 30% measured │ ├── 06 japan population surveys.md JPSC-AD ascertainment confound │ ├── 07 gbd diagnostic results.md the flat surface + the placebo │ └── 08 ontario conversion schedule.md reusable artifact: 1949–59 dates ├── data/ │ ├── raw/ Untouched downloads + PROVENANCE.md every source, every step │ ├── reference/ prefecture→frequency map + the 5 conversions, fully cited │ └── processed/ Derived. Safe to delete and regenerate. ├── src/ Numbered pipeline; agestd.py has 11 passing tests ├── figures/ gbd diagnostic.png └── output/ Model results — a data/reference/ time-varying Japanese prefecture-frequency map covering five documented conversions 1943–61 , fully cited, including corrections to errors that have propagated through Wikipedia for fifteen years.— a collated Ontario municipal conversion schedule 1949–59 , which does not appear to exist elsewhere. docs/08 pip install -r requirements.txt python src/01 build frequency map.py builds prefecture→frequency reference table python src/02 fetch data.py downloads raw data see PROVENANCE.md for manual steps python src/03 age standardize.py direct standardisation to reference population python src/04 analysis.py primary + placebo models Any step requiring manual download data-use agreements, API keys is documented in data/raw/PROVENANCE.md with exact instructions rather than being silently skipped. | Decision | Choice | Why | |---|---|---| | Outcome measure | Prevalence and incidence where available | Mortality ≈ coding practice | | Standardisation | Direct, 5-year bands to 95+ | Risk doubles every ~5 yrs; coarse bands leave residual confounding | | Geographic unit | Municipality where possible, prefecture as fallback | n=47 prefectures has near-zero power | | Primary design | Spatial regression discontinuity at the frequency boundary | The only place frequency is plausibly exogenous | | Falsification | Placebo outcomes across the same boundary | If colorectal cancer also jumps, the design is broken | 0. The Japan study cannot be done with public data — and this is the useful result. Not "underpowered." Not assemblable. Japan's 介護DB does publish real, measured dementia assessments 認知症高齢者自立度 , and it does have municipality geography 1,571 insurers, coded — but never crossed. The municipality file carries only application category and care level; dementia stops at prefecture. And dementia × prefecture has no age dimension, so it cannot be age-standardised — meaning a prefecture analysis would reproduce the exact artefact that discredited the original chart. Verified empirically; files retained in data/raw/kaigodb/ . See docs/03 japan data availability.md . Unblocking needs a formal MHLW 介護DB application Japanese institution + ethics, multi-month for a design already known to detect only a ~31% effect. Four further findings, in descending order of how much they change the project. 1. There is a much better experiment than Japan, and it is in Ontario. Southwestern Ontario ran at 25 Hz until a 1949–59 conversion. 25 Hz mains produces 50 Hz luminous flicker — visible, and in the gamma band . That population is the only large human group ever to have lived under sustained ambient flicker near 40 Hz, which is essentially the GENUS condition delivered unintentionally for decades. It gives a signed prediction, a continuous dose, within-municipality cohort variation, and individual-level ICES data. See docs/02 the ontario 25hz experiment.md . 2. The Japan design cannot detect a plausible effect. The design with power has no identification; the design with identification has no power. The confirmatory variant RD within Shizuoka has an MDE of ~31% of baseline prevalence . Expected outcome is therefore uninformative, not null — a materially different claim. METHODS.md §9. 3. GBD subnational is probably unusable for this question. GBD 2021 does contain all 47 prefectures verified live . But IHME's own Japan paper says: "GBD disease models compensate by using regional data and covariates, potentially resulting in minimal regional variation ... due to limited Japanese data coverage." Our exposure varies between prefectures; if the outcome's between-prefecture variation is model output, the test is near-circular. data/raw/PROVENANCE.md §4. 4. The original chart's gaps are smaller than its own uncontrolled confounder. Age structure alone, with zero effect present, generates a 1.75× crude gap in a realistic Japan-like contrast. The chart's gaps are ~1.04× and ~1.13×. Run python src/test agestd.py . This is a low-prior hypothesis being given a fair test. We are pre-registering because the researcher degrees of freedom here are enormous and we would certainly find something if we looked freely.